Wikimedia Foundation turns down Phorm

About this blog

Communication Breakdown

Communications from the world of, er, communications. And other stuff.

The Wikimedia Foundation has become the latest web giant to opt out of Phorm's user-tracking targeted-advertising system.

After Amazon did the same earlier this week, Wikimedia took the plunge on Thursday, "after some internal discussion on whether opting out of the Phorm user-profiling system in the UK would legitimize it".

The move means that users of Wikipedia and other Wikimedia properties cannot have their surfing tracked across those sites by Phorm/Webwise.

Unlike Amazon, which gave no explicit reason for its decision, Wikimedia outlined its motivation to the Phorm/Webwise folks: "...we consider the scanning and profiling of our visitors' behavior by a third party to be an infringement on their privacy".

Talkback

From a check of how their shares are trading I'd say Phorm is a few small steps from the bottom of a steady decline.

The Chairman's Statement alone on the website says it all.

'Company operating losses for the six month period ended 30 June 2008 were $25.6 million.'

And we all know just how much the economy has changed since then. Whatever the case, I think their model is way off the mark. In fact, it's miles away.

I could easily crush it with a paltry mill or 2.


TFD

thinkfeeldo 18 April, 2009 07:22 Reply

What the hell did they expect? Far too open for such a project to succeed. I'd happily bet that if there is going to be any "snooping" done on peoples surfing habits, then it's going to be done in a covert/sneaky kind of way.

roger andre 19 April, 2009 00:39 Reply

Roger, what a sad comment!

Moley 19 April, 2009 01:12 Reply

Ah yes a little hot under the collar with that one. Just seems bizzare not to expect a reaction when you shout from the roof tops that you have a business model based on intercepting surfing habits.

Then again maybe that's part of a plan to draw in free publicity. Sure as hell worked if it was, but sadly for them may backfire.

One of my concerns is that it may slow down the web. Is that possible?

roger andre 19 April, 2009 19:08 Reply

Roger, Roger, Roger...slow down the web? You were on the right path with your 1st comment. In the end, profiling is the only way in which advertising will truly succeed online. It's just how company's like Phorm go about obtaining the info. How many people do you think read every web site Privacy statement? The collection of data, habits, models of personal use, whatever you want to call them, are really about predictive intelligence systems which I have mentioned on several other posts since joining ZDNet.

Simple premise: I know, what you know, therefore I can push what I believe you will want/ need etc.

TFD

thinkfeeldo 21 April, 2009 06:05 Reply

And of course, what Phorm does isn't hugely different from Google's adsense, which hasn't raised as much of a stink.

Though, i'm not sure why not

filthylooker 21 April, 2009 12:32 Reply

Perhaps because there is an element of choice and Google is not physically located in our ISP scrutinising *all* of our traffic, Phorm does this whether we are opted in or opted out and could possibly be subverted quite easily to 'spy' on us all.

As to whether Phorm, adsense etc. do slow down the web, I have been wondering about that in particular reference to ZDNet's own site. It is without doubt one of the slowest sites to load and I'm curious to know if this has something to do with ZDNet's arrangements for advertising which are causing this slowness.

Moley 21 April, 2009 18:25 Reply

Ah Moley yes ZDNet has some swanky flash based ads and videos ready to go on load up.

The Firefox Add-on 'Ad Block Plus' (ABP) may cure such slowness, It did for me. It also gives you a more tidy visual experience on the web and you can right click some ads that you do see and set it to block them.

Whoops, can I say that on here?

roger andre 21 April, 2009 21:45 Reply

The "element of choice" is only available to people who are aware of the opt out facility. I have an adsense account for my own website, yet don't know how to go about opting out of the service with my "web user" hat on.

Also while google can't see all of our web usage, there are an awful lot of websites with "ads by google" and each time we visit, google can - and do - track it.

filthylooker 22 April, 2009 12:55 Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in

Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

ForceCloud

#Force #Cloud Is Your Enterprise Architecture Stifling Innovation?: Ever heard of Salesforce.com? How many IT ... http://bit.ly/d8imwO #TCN

ezcomputerhelp

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard?: By TamaraDigitalis, 2 September, 2010 22:14 I'ma Social Media Execut... http://bit.ly/dxWaSN

jackschofield

Tablet market turns Android at IFA, by me at ZD Net http://bit.ly/cOkmt7

fauzanmohd

EA: Is Your Enterprise Architecture Stifling Innovation?: By CastlePointe, 2 September, 2010 23:55 IT organization... http://bit.ly/aSQnc6

awhodunit

Is Your Enterprise Architecture Stifling Innovation? http://bit.ly/dm79Bk

superrricky

Is Your Enterprise Architecture Stifling Innovation? http://bit.ly/c3frsK

bankruptcy_reno

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard? http://bit.ly/cGLCtb

ejmullings

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard? http://bit.ly/9g6WbK #socialmedia

theMediaDude

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard? http://bit.ly/az2ZU6

electricitydeal

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard?: ... US" Now there's one sentence there that really leaps out at me, ... http://bit.ly/cPCLep

everlastgogreen

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard? http://bit.ly/9K1jFz

Jodie_Greenpeace

A quick correction to your post is that our previous Leaderboard listed Intel as the largest purchaser of renewable energy in the U.S., not the...

3 hours ago by Jodie_Greenpeace on Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard?
Jodie_Greenpeace

A quick correction to your post is that our previous Leaderboard listed Intel as the largest purchaser of renewable energy in the U.S., not the...

3 hours ago by Jodie_Greenpeace
internet_know

Ad watchdog given teeth for online marketing: From 1 March anyone who has a concern about a marketing communicatio... http://bit.ly/bZxVO6

EMSPublications

Ad watchdog given teeth for online marketing http://bit.ly/bCuubi

7y5

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard? http://bit.ly/9Ts9zc

OurGreenEnergy

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard?: Greenpeace says: "The IT sector possesses the innovative spirit, tec... http://bit.ly/aqzYMt

1energysource

Who tops the Greenpeace Cool IT leaderboard? http://bit.ly/aKsiID

Jack Schofield

@apexwm I discussed this endlessly with senior people at all the big netbook suppliers including UK marketing and managing directors, a director...

4 hours ago by Jack Schofield on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
Jack Schofield

@Chris Rankin > Just comparing apples with apples, Jack. And Microsoft isn't a charity - it > doesn't in any way deserve a donation of a "measly...

5 hours ago by Jack Schofield on UK PC sales up 15%, but growth is weaker than in Western Europe

Featured white papers

The benefits of email archiving

Email archiving lowers the risk of being unable to find important documents and help in achieving regulatory compliance and answering litigation requests.

Download now

Cloud Computing - What does it really mean?

Technology transforming business - The term cloud is used as a metaphor for the Internet, based on how theInternet is depicted..

Download now

Out-of-box Comparison Between Dell, HP and IBM blade servers

This compelling paper by Principled Technologies compares out-of-box experiences on Dell PowerEdge M600 Blade System, HP BladeSystem..

Download now

Community highlights

Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe

2010: The Year We Make (Email) Contact

Blog Post It's been an interesting few days here in our office, as I took the...

2 September, 2010 by Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe
Rupert Goodwins

ZDNet UK: there is, as they say, an app for that

Blog Post It's small, it's simple, it does one job well - and it's ours. And you can...

2 September, 2010 by Rupert Goodwins
sid18

TalkBack People have seen how Apple dominated the MP3 market with the iPod and so when...

1 September, 2010 by sid18