How Obama watched the Bin Laden mission

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

About this blog

ZD Staff

Mixed Signals

Any sufficiently advanced information is indistinguishable from noise

One of the unexpected revelations of the operation that assassinated Bin Laden was that President Obama watched it happen on live video from the White House. Although modern warfare is an extremely interconnected affair, with battlefield awareness provided by large numbers of carefully managed data streams, it turns out that the system which gave Obama a soldier's eye view of action on the ground in Pakistan is Internet-based, and not so far from how anyone would Skype from a holiday destination.

Although there's been no official information about the system used, it was almost certainly the ArcLight mobile broadband system from ViaSat, which also runs the Yonder in-flight Internet and data system. The company announced in July 2008 that a militarised, secure version for COTM (Communications On The Move) had been sold to the American Special Operations Command (USSOCOM) and had already been deployed in the Middle East, with rapid expansion promised. As the company said at the time,"This new operational capability [is] primarily for sending high resolution video back to higher command authorities for further analysis and identification". Data is relayed from terminals on the ground, in vehicles or in flight, to one of a number of satellites where ViaSat lease radio bandwidth, then sent on to an appropriate ground station where it's coupled into public networks.

The system is now fitted to American Black Hawk helicopters as used in the Bin Laden mission, most likely in the VMT-1220HE helicopter-specific configuration, as well as to 'several dozen' light MC-12 reconnaissance aircraft and multiple C-130 command and control aircraft. The C-130 fitting comes on a door, which replaces one of the aircraft's emergency exit hatches and can be swapped in or out swiftly.

ArcLight is used commercially to provide broadband to helicopters and private jets, Operating in the Ku band with a 14 GHz uplink and downlinks between 11 and 13 GHz, it can be configured in a number of ways, including 10Mbps down/512Kbps up or a symmetrical 3Mbps. The VMT-1220HE on the Black Hawk helicopters supports channel speeds of up to 5 Mbps to, and up to 325 kbps from the helicopter, which means President Obama probably didn't see the mission in HD, although with three aircraft bonding their uplinks together for close-on a megabit, it would have been possible.

With a 25 watt uplink via an 11.5 cm antenna and spread-spectrum modulation, coupled with a protocol designed to send packets in bursts, it's robust and forgiving of obstructions like helicopter blades, and will have good performance against jamming and other interference.

Although the published coverage maps for Yonder, which shares infrastructure with Arclight, show that the northern half of Pakistan is on the borders of an area not due to be covered until the third quarter of 2011, there are various ways that bandwidth can be provided out of published specification, including temporary movement of satellites, borrowing time from other operators and so on. ViaSat had expected to launch its own 130 Gbps satellite, ViaSat-1 early in 2011, but after the satellite was damaged during testing that launch has been put back to summer this year.

A great deal of security is built into the system. The American National Security Agency (NSA), which was involved in the mission, has built classified networks such as  SIPRNet (Secret Internet Protocol Router Network) and JWICS (Joint Worldwide Intelligence Communications System) that the ArcLight COTM can connect to. Devices like ViaSat's AltaSec KG-250X provide encryption and other secure IP management features at up to 100Mbps full-duplex, so local wireless comms in a location can be turned into a secure enclave with full protection. This level of security is generically known as TS/SCI - Top Secret/Sensitive Compartmented Information, and is essential for highly sensitive government data on shared infrastructure public networks.

Using this sort of configuration, any portable streaming wireless webcam can be easily made part of the secure network, with megabit bandwidth back to anywhere in the world – including operations rooms in the White House.

Talkback

Just out of interest, the helicopter that was lost on the raid was probably not a Black Hawk, but a hitherto unknown type. There's some spirited discussion and pictures in the military section of the ever-entertaining Pprune forum here - http://www.pprune.org/military-aircrew/450526-stealth-uh60-used-obl-raid.html

Which is a reminder that my analysis, above, should be taken with an even bigger pinch of salt than previously.

Rupert Goodwins 4 May, 2011 10:59
Reply

Thanks Rupert, for this and the link, I love reading this stuff... jw

J.A. Watson 4 May, 2011 12:37
Reply

:-)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link_16

We've been putting this on birds, ships, etc for the last couple years. (I have a fun job)

sfshilo 4 May, 2011 17:51
Reply

The last thing I heard on this was that the President didn't actually watch it live, unlike first reported. Something about the feed cutting out, apparently? I've lost the link to that article, though.

I've also lost count of how many aspects of this story that changed since it was first reported. (They can't blame the "fog of war" any more either because now we're told there was very little "war" to speak of)

http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/05/the-slippery-story-of-the-bin-laden-kill/238261/

authentictech 9 May, 2011 18:42
Reply

I found the link I previously referred to:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/al-qaeda/8493391/Osama-bin-Laden-dead-Blackout-during-raid-on-bin-Laden-compound.html

"The head of the CIA admitted yesterday that there was no live video footage of the raid on Osama bin Laden's compound as further doubts emerged about the US version of events."

This raises the question of why several national newspapers (Daily Mail especially) were spinning stories about how Obama watched Osama take a bullet in the face live on TV etc.

One has to wonder how much of news reporting nowadays is just repeating stories verbatim as fed in from without any credible fact-checking or investigation (probably quite a lot). In this case, where facts are not/cannot be confirmed, the correct response of journalism is to say "so-and-so said/claimed...".

(I'm not suggesting any wrong-doing on behalf of the author of this article as this is a technical blog and ZDNet isn't a newspaper).

authentictech 9 May, 2011 20:20
Reply

Well, in this case I knew that American special forces had been installing live video systems specifically designed to provide front-line pictures up the chain of command. This was, as I hope was clear from the article, an exploration of how it would happen - although my assumption was that it had, there's plenty of fog around this sort of thing. The stuff reported is, I hope, of interest and as far as I can tell accurate.

According to that D Tel piece, there was live video for some of the raid, so something of the sort went on! I doubt that two parallel systems would be in place, especially as the levels of security and coverage that the Viasat system is reported as providing are more than up to the job.

Rupert Goodwins via Facebook 10 May, 2011 14:50
Reply

Thanks, Rupert. That's how I took it. The article was indeed interesting. I have just been raging a bit at some newspapers recently but it probably wasn't really appropriate to comment on that here. Though I did think it was of minor interest to know that whatever system they were using didn't extend to the Whitehouse, unlike most news sources reported it.

It would have certainly still reached whoever was controlling the mission and could have potentially reached the Whitehouse, but I doubt that would have been at all desirable, as I doubt any of them would really have wanted to see people (potentially women, children and their own men) getting shot live on telly!

authentictech 10 May, 2011 17:02
Reply

For all we know, OBL could be at gitmo being waterboarded at this time. The story changes every day, it seems.

ITOdeed 24 May, 2011 15:22
Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

Burn-IT

Skittles with tapes and coffee cups. Old tapes so we didn't have to rewind them afterwards.

6 minutes ago by Burn-IT on Ten IT jobs to save up for those rare lulls
Fraud_fighter

What is mildly amusing to me is when someone thinks a strong password is as strong as one may need, when the truth is usernames and passwords are...

43 minutes ago by Fraud_fighter on Passwords are here to stay: get used to it
Andy Bolstridge

Performance isn't really the big thing at the moment - not when my ADSL connection will only provide a 8mbps bottleneck to the 3.5gbps speeds these...

1 hour ago by Andy Bolstridge via Facebook on Next-generation 802.11ac routers
pjc158

So when is Amazon buying Waterstones?

3 hours ago by pjc158 on Waterstones to sell Kindles with in-store offers
J.A. Watson

@JoshArg - Well, I am writing this from my N150 Plus, running Ubuntu 12.04 and using a Bluetooth mouse (well, to be totally correct it is a...

3 hours ago by J.A. Watson on Samsung N150 Plus Netbook - Ubuntu Netbook Edition 10.04
J.A. Watson

@duncanjmurray - At least n the case of the specific system I put the SSD into, it is not the case. The boot time improvement is substantial, but...

3 hours ago by J.A. Watson on Netbook Upgrade - SSD IN, Windows OUT
archerthom

Sounds like only those who have bought their Kindle from Waterstones will be able to use them in-store - very disappointing. I have no intention...

5 hours ago by archerthom on Waterstones to sell Kindles with in-store offers
AndyPagin

From my mainframe operating days... 1) Play hoopla with write permit rings & a can of screen cleaner. 2) Make enormous paper chains (Christmas...

6 hours ago by AndyPagin on Ten IT jobs to save up for those rare lulls
61253

An OS X perspective Filenames beginning with a dot/period (.) should not be equated with HFS Plus resource forks; misunderstandings around ._ (dot...

6 hours ago by 61253 on SharePoint deployment: Pitfalls of a pioneer
ians1

There are many legal download sites for music at least that do not charge an arm and a leg like itunes or Napster. The "real" cost of an mp3 file...

7 hours ago by ians1 on The Pirate Bay infringes copyright, High Court decides
Jon Howells

@Crupal.. How does refusing your websites cookies help my privacy? A quick look at your page script reveals four sets of code provided by 3rd...

14 hours ago by Jon Howells via Facebook on Privacy watchdog to chase big companies over cookie law
Paul Carloss

There are hundreds, if not thousands of filesharing torrent sites, The Pirate Bay (TPB) is only one of them, while the TPB is blocked many more...

15 hours ago by Paul Carloss via Facebook on The Pirate Bay infringes copyright, High Court decides
Rebin Simpson

So could users DownGrade if the new OS didn't worked correctly ?

18 hours ago by Rebin Simpson on Sony delivers on Xperia Ice Cream Sandwich promise
duncanjmurray

Hmmm, I thought that with SSDs you could get to the mythical ubuntu 10 sec boot time? Is this not the case?

18 hours ago by duncanjmurray on Netbook Upgrade - SSD IN, Windows OUT
JoshArg

Thanks once again! I have installed Linux Mint 13 (Maya) everything runs well but.. bluetooh is not present, "there is no blueetooth adapter" do...

18 hours ago by JoshArg on Samsung N150 Plus Netbook - Ubuntu Netbook Edition 10.04
zdnetukuser

@JAW-- There’s a better-than-even chance that, had you made another choice of SSD, you would have noticed no improvement in battery life...

2 days ago by zdnetukuser on Netbook Upgrade - SSD IN, Windows OUT
Amb Rose

Please stop connecting the 'ATeam' to the UK Anonymous collective. Anonymous and the ATeam are not connected. The ATeam are not part of, affiliated...

2 days ago by Amb Rose via Facebook on UK Anonymous keeps up DDoS barrage on ICO
cpupal

Hi All I have looked into the cookie law today, there are a few solutions that these websites can use. Just add the widget and update your policy...

2 days ago by cpupal on Privacy watchdog to chase big companies over cookie law
dropz42

I read that many of the governments own websites are not yet compliant...shouldn't they sort that out before chasing others - slightly hypocritical !

2 days ago by dropz42 on Privacy watchdog to chase big companies over cookie law
Charles McLellan

@larrylisser Thanks for the feedback; you're quite right to surmise that the article's main point was to inform about developments in cloud-based...

2 days ago by Charles McLellan on VideoMeet: cloud-based video communication

Community highlights

manek

Passwords are here to stay: get used to it

Blog Post It's been mildly amusing to see, once more, a vendor of two-factor...

21 May, 2012 by manek
First Take

Next-generation 802.11ac routers

Blog Post A recent flurry of announcements from networking equipment vendors —...

21 May, 2012 by First Take
Jack Schofield

The three big questions about Facebook's IPO

Blog Post The three big questions about Facebook's stock exchange launch are: (1) Is it...

18 May, 2012 by Jack Schofield
Jack Schofield

Cardbox database goes from £299 to free

Blog Post Thirty years after Cardbox released its flat-file database of that name, the...

18 May, 2012 by Jack Schofield