White space standard gets lukewarm reception

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

About this blog

ZD Staff

Mixed Signals

Any sufficiently advanced information is indistinguishable from noise

American standards body the IEEE has finished work on 802.22.1 and 802.22.2, part of the 802.22 standard for white space radio. This defines how wireless broadband systems can interleave themselves between other signals, potentially opening up unused spectrum in previously allocated bands.

With theoretical maximum figures of 100km range and speeds of up to 22Mbps, 802.22 is designed to bring internet access to remote rural areas through wireless regional area networks (Wrans). However, with each cell supporting a maximum of 12 users, one cell at maximum range would support a population density of one user for every 82 square kilometres, 650 times more sparse than the Scottish Highlands.

802.22 is designed to operate between 54 and 698 MHz, mostly within broadcast TV spectrum. By sensing which channels are in use, referring to a database of known transmitters, and adjusting its own transmissions to eliminate interference, 802.22 is designed to automatically morph its own presence to fit around existing services.

UK white space pioneer Neul, which is developing its own Weightless standard said in a statement that while it was pleased to see white space ideas endorsed it was not going to adopt 802.22 initially, although it would review this if the standard proved successful.

"802.22 is designed for rural broadband: high bandwidth, high power terminals and a relatively small number of users per basestation. The Weightless standard is aimed entirely at M2M [machine to machine]: low bandwidth, extremely low power terminals and many thousands of devices per basestation. The standards do not compete at all," the company said.

"[We] have a high bandwidth mode that can be used for rural broadband. This already offers similar performance to that promised by 802.22. We are believers in open standards for wireless devices and may adopt 802.22 if it is successful. However, such standards are most valuable where it is essential to ensure interoperability between devices from different manufacturers. This is not really the case for rural broadband because most installations use access point and the consumer premises equipment from the same manufacturer," Neul said.

The company also said that it doubted the rural broadband market was big enough to support economic development of the necessary custom chips, and M2M was needed in addition to make the market large enough for commercial exploitation.

Talkback

This post has been removed by a moderator.

Hey, the UK reporter understands the American standards better than our own reporters do! I keep reading that everybody wants to use this to log on to their home network. >< Apparently the idea of a wireless router that fits on your desk and broadcasts 62 miles is perfectly logical over here. Thank you also for the Weightless angle; it's interesting to see how regional carriers respond to the new standard.

Kevin Kelley via Facebook 31 July, 2011 08:01
Reply

This post has been removed by a moderator.

This post has been removed by a moderator.

This post has been removed by a moderator.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

Burn-IT

Skittles with tapes and coffee cups. Old tapes so we didn't have to rewind them afterwards.

19 minutes ago by Burn-IT on Ten IT jobs to save up for those rare lulls
Fraud_fighter

What is mildly amusing to me is when someone thinks a strong password is as strong as one may need, when the truth is usernames and passwords are...

55 minutes ago by Fraud_fighter on Passwords are here to stay: get used to it
Andy Bolstridge

Performance isn't really the big thing at the moment - not when my ADSL connection will only provide a 8mbps bottleneck to the 3.5gbps speeds these...

1 hour ago by Andy Bolstridge via Facebook on Next-generation 802.11ac routers
pjc158

So when is Amazon buying Waterstones?

3 hours ago by pjc158 on Waterstones to sell Kindles with in-store offers
J.A. Watson

@JoshArg - Well, I am writing this from my N150 Plus, running Ubuntu 12.04 and using a Bluetooth mouse (well, to be totally correct it is a...

3 hours ago by J.A. Watson on Samsung N150 Plus Netbook - Ubuntu Netbook Edition 10.04
J.A. Watson

@duncanjmurray - At least n the case of the specific system I put the SSD into, it is not the case. The boot time improvement is substantial, but...

3 hours ago by J.A. Watson on Netbook Upgrade - SSD IN, Windows OUT
archerthom

Sounds like only those who have bought their Kindle from Waterstones will be able to use them in-store - very disappointing. I have no intention...

5 hours ago by archerthom on Waterstones to sell Kindles with in-store offers
AndyPagin

From my mainframe operating days... 1) Play hoopla with write permit rings & a can of screen cleaner. 2) Make enormous paper chains (Christmas...

6 hours ago by AndyPagin on Ten IT jobs to save up for those rare lulls
61253

An OS X perspective Filenames beginning with a dot/period (.) should not be equated with HFS Plus resource forks; misunderstandings around ._ (dot...

6 hours ago by 61253 on SharePoint deployment: Pitfalls of a pioneer
ians1

There are many legal download sites for music at least that do not charge an arm and a leg like itunes or Napster. The "real" cost of an mp3 file...

8 hours ago by ians1 on The Pirate Bay infringes copyright, High Court decides
Jon Howells

@Crupal.. How does refusing your websites cookies help my privacy? A quick look at your page script reveals four sets of code provided by 3rd...

14 hours ago by Jon Howells via Facebook on Privacy watchdog to chase big companies over cookie law
Paul Carloss

There are hundreds, if not thousands of filesharing torrent sites, The Pirate Bay (TPB) is only one of them, while the TPB is blocked many more...

15 hours ago by Paul Carloss via Facebook on The Pirate Bay infringes copyright, High Court decides
Rebin Simpson

So could users DownGrade if the new OS didn't worked correctly ?

18 hours ago by Rebin Simpson on Sony delivers on Xperia Ice Cream Sandwich promise
duncanjmurray

Hmmm, I thought that with SSDs you could get to the mythical ubuntu 10 sec boot time? Is this not the case?

18 hours ago by duncanjmurray on Netbook Upgrade - SSD IN, Windows OUT
JoshArg

Thanks once again! I have installed Linux Mint 13 (Maya) everything runs well but.. bluetooh is not present, "there is no blueetooth adapter" do...

19 hours ago by JoshArg on Samsung N150 Plus Netbook - Ubuntu Netbook Edition 10.04
zdnetukuser

@JAW-- There’s a better-than-even chance that, had you made another choice of SSD, you would have noticed no improvement in battery life...

2 days ago by zdnetukuser on Netbook Upgrade - SSD IN, Windows OUT
Amb Rose

Please stop connecting the 'ATeam' to the UK Anonymous collective. Anonymous and the ATeam are not connected. The ATeam are not part of, affiliated...

2 days ago by Amb Rose via Facebook on UK Anonymous keeps up DDoS barrage on ICO
cpupal

Hi All I have looked into the cookie law today, there are a few solutions that these websites can use. Just add the widget and update your policy...

2 days ago by cpupal on Privacy watchdog to chase big companies over cookie law
dropz42

I read that many of the governments own websites are not yet compliant...shouldn't they sort that out before chasing others - slightly hypocritical !

2 days ago by dropz42 on Privacy watchdog to chase big companies over cookie law
Charles McLellan

@larrylisser Thanks for the feedback; you're quite right to surmise that the article's main point was to inform about developments in cloud-based...

2 days ago by Charles McLellan on VideoMeet: cloud-based video communication

Community highlights

manek

Passwords are here to stay: get used to it

Blog Post It's been mildly amusing to see, once more, a vendor of two-factor...

21 May, 2012 by manek
First Take

Next-generation 802.11ac routers

Blog Post A recent flurry of announcements from networking equipment vendors —...

21 May, 2012 by First Take
Jack Schofield

The three big questions about Facebook's IPO

Blog Post The three big questions about Facebook's stock exchange launch are: (1) Is it...

18 May, 2012 by Jack Schofield
Jack Schofield

Cardbox database goes from £299 to free

Blog Post Thirty years after Cardbox released its flat-file database of that name, the...

18 May, 2012 by Jack Schofield