ZDNet UK / News and Analysis / Application Development

Row erupts over software patent directive

By Jerome Thorel and Matt Loney, ZDNet.co.uk, 21 February, 2002 17:50

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

Topics

Patent, eurolinux, Francisco Mingorance, european commission directive on software patents, BSA, Patent Office

NEWS
The European Commission's directive on software patents has come under severe criticism for bowing to the needs of big business at the expense of small software developers and consumers. At the centre of the controversy is the revelation that the "author" of a draft copy of the directive appears to be a key employee of the Business Software Alliance, a group that represents the interests of big businesses, including Microsoft. The directive is seen as a crucial test of the European Commission's determination to resist pressure from US government and business interests to relax the laws governing software patents. Advocates of such relaxation say it is necessary to allow European companies to compete on a level playing field with American companies. Current EU regulations are supposed to stop patents being granted for software that has no technical merit. Such software patents are widely granted in the US for software that, critics argue, is little more than a business process. Such patents, they say, mainly serve the interests of patent lawyers and make it difficult to create new software without being exposed to lawsuits by big corporate patent holders. Many issues have been discovered in the EC's draft directive, but the most worrying is the involvement of the BSA, according to the EuroLinux Alliance, an open coalition of commercial companies and non-profit associations that has been a vigorous campaigner on the issue. The draft -- a Microsoft Word document -- circulated by EuroLinux, contains in the author's field the name of the BSA European director of public policy, Francisco Mingorance. This is proof, says EuroLinux, of the BSA's involvement in drafting the directive. In an interview with ZDNet UK, Mingorance said he did not know how his name came to be associated with the document. "I don't know how or why my name was put on -- we have nothing to do with it, other than presenting our proposals," he said. "For the Commission it is insulting to say someone else is writing the proposal." In fact, said Mingorance, if the BSA had had a hand in drafting the document, it would have changed a key aspect of the directive, which states that patents only apply to computers running software, not to the software itself. "This means that if someone is infringing your patent you cannot directly sue him; only when an end user is running it on a machine can you build a case to show that the person who wrote or sold the software is a contributory infringer. This will be more expensive for patent-holders." "I look at this document," said Mingorance, "and it is not what we were proposing. We would rather see what is currently the European practice generalised to member states." But the problem for the BSA is that many observers are now convinced that Mignorance -- or another BSA representative in Brussels -- had access to the document as early as 6 February. Speaking to ZDNet France, Jean-Paul Smets of EuroLinux said: "With this date, the draft directive should never have left the Commission. I do not think that BSA wrote the proposal, but nevertheless it is clear that the BSA had access to the document in a completely irregular way. EuroLinux has many contacts in Brussels, and they always refused to communicate the project to us before it was made public." John Todd, a spokesperson for the Internal Market Commissioner's office, which is responsible for the directive on software patents, said he was not aware of the accusations against the BSA. A spokesman for the UK Patent Office dismissed the idea that the draft could have been written by the BSA as a "conspiracy theory". "I will not say big business did not have a input into the legislation," he said, "but so did everybody else." The Patent Office spokesman maintained that the message from a consultative exercise carried out in preparation for the draft directive was "to maintain the status quo. We will not go down the American route" of allowing patents for software that does not have a technical effect. "Software will still have to undergo exactly same test as any other patent application; novelty, obviousness and technical effect. If you take a handwritten ledger and write a piece of software to electronically produce it, that has no technical effect. But if you have software that makes a robotic arm more accurate or quicker, then there is a technical effect. (The directive) should be in tune with that." He stressed that the commission has not yet approved the directive. But regardless of the BSA's involvement, critics say many questions about the proposed software patents policy remain unanswered. High among these, said EuroLinux, are key differences between the draft document and the final one. "The document of the (final) directive is incomplete," said EuroLinux in a statement. "All the arguments which allow (one) to decide whether this directive is legal or not according to the Treaty of Rome have disappeared. The press release also contains many sentences which are contradictory with the content of the directive." EuroLinux said that contrary to official explanations, the directive does indeed propose to legalise the granting of computer programs as such in Europe. "The proposed regulation is embedded in a long advocacy text which tries to give a rationale for this proposal," it said. "This text disregards the opinions of most if not all respected software developers and economists, instead (relying) on dogmatic statements about patents in general as well as some unsubstantiated claims and even some outright lies, citing as its only source of information about the real world of software a study from BSA about the importance of copyright enforcement. This study apparently does not even deal with the subject of patents." EuroLinux is convinced that the wording of the directive will legalise US-style software patents in Europe "and remove all effective limits on patentability." In the US, lawsuits over software have proliferated, and noted intellectuals such as Stanford Law School professor and technology pundit Lawrence Lessig have increasingly attacked the status quo. Speaking at LinuxWorld last August, Lessig said the desire of entrenched commercial interests to control information is crushing the spirit of innovation that allowed the Internet to blossom. Copyright and patent law, ostensibly designed to protect innovation, now have become tools large companies can use to maintain their dominance and control, Lessig said in his keynote address. "The old will defeat the new unless you do something to prevent it," Lessig cautioned his audience full of programmers and advocates of open-source software at LinuxWorld. "Your life will be increasingly regulated by those who say what's permitted... The consequence of this will be to recentralise the process of innovation." Among the more highly publicised examples of patents awarded in the US for what critics say are little more than business processes, are Priceline.com's patent for reverse auctions and Amazon.com's patent for one-click ordering, which simply remembers a user's details when they return to the site. Stung by criticism, Amazon chief executive Jeff Bezos later called for an overhaul of the US patent process to reflect the different nature of software innovation.
See the Software News Section for the latest headlines on everything from peer to peer clients to Office software and beyond. Have your say instantly, and see what others have said. Go to the ZDNet news forum. Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.

Related stories

IBM tops US patent list again

BT to press ahead on hyperlink case

German government opposes software patents

Open-source advocate attacks patent laws

Perens: Linux could learn from Apple

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

apexwm

Bill Goodrich : Just as al_langevin pointed out, with Windows Server 2008 there is no Services for Macintosh anymore. It's gone, not available....

7 hours ago by apexwm on Windows Server 2008 drops the ball for Mac compatibility
txtrainguy

Replying to an old topic that I'm currently facing with my CEO (who is on a Mac). Our servers are primarily Windows Servers, office is about...

14 hours ago by txtrainguy on Windows Server 2008 drops the ball for Mac compatibility
k0tcs3

Sure, that makes perfect sense. Pay wrong-doers money and thank them for breaching your security and pointing out your flaws, that would surely...

14 hours ago by k0tcs3 on US indicts Romanian over NASA climate change hack
Random_Error

I think he's referring specifically to Android apps, as Apple do regulate their App Store, but Google seem to let any old crap onto the Android store!

14 hours ago by Random_Error on RIM: BlackBerry will keep 'garbage' apps out of store
Paul Fezziwig

Keep the crap apps out?! How will they compete with Android and Apple's claim to fame of having so many life changing apps? I wonder if the media...

20 hours ago by Paul Fezziwig via Facebook on RIM: BlackBerry will keep 'garbage' apps out of store
Aigars Mahinovs

It has been shown time after time that if there is an author store that sells the songs at even 1$ per song and gives you a high-quality digital...

20 hours ago by Aigars Mahinovs via Facebook on Copyright isn't working, says European Commission
awbMaven

""As a result of Butyka's alleged conduct, researchers were unable to use the computers for more than two months while NASA removed the malicious...

23 hours ago by awbMaven on US indicts Romanian over NASA climate change hack
subhorup

It simultaneously worries me and uplifts me that a self-proclaimed group of internet activists name themselves after Indian mythical figures....

1 day ago by subhorup on Anonymous activists release PCAnywhere source code
naviathan

It's actually far easier to work anonymously on the internet than you think. With tools like Tor bouncing your traffic around the world before...

1 day ago by naviathan on Anonymous activists release PCAnywhere source code
Agnostic_OS

1000272134 and bluedalmatian with you both there but then I'm still in 10.04 land (and happy with it)

1 day ago by Agnostic_OS on Ten factors that make Ubuntu 11.10 a hit
apexwm

Interesting article and definitely see your points on the products mentioned. One of the top products for our Help Desk (approximately 20% of all...

2 days ago by apexwm on Ten flawed products that derail productivity
Paul Hutchinson

Absolutely - this should obviously not be handled my isp - but handled by their hosting operator. What's been suggested here is that my isp police...

2 days ago by Paul Hutchinson via Facebook on MPs urge ISPs to take down terrorist material
Techs UK

Looks like a great phone. I don't notice any deficiencies in WP7. used IOS before, that's pretty good. I don't spend much time in Apps, all i need...

2 days ago by Techs UK on Nokia pins US 're-entry' hopes on Lumia 900
Larry Bloggy

Now with the help of these apps you are always synced with MS outlook while on the move. Just download apps like xobni or outlookreflex and get...

2 days ago by Larry Bloggy via Facebook on Outlook Social Connector beta 2 and the LinkedIn connector
mike40g123

Your details are wrong. The version currently being made is the one with 2 USB ports, 256MB RAM and a network port. This is the Model B. The...

2 days ago by mike40g123 on Raspberry Pi boards set to go on sale
Moley

The thing that has been puzzling me for quite a while is how Anonymous can remain anonymous whilst not only being active on the Internet but also...

3 days ago by Moley on Anonymous activists release PCAnywhere source code
Don Dilly

If what Semantec is saying is rue, that is even worse and shows a complete disregard for thier users. If what Anonymous claims is true and the...

3 days ago by Don Dilly via Facebook on Anonymous activists release PCAnywhere source code
MattChurchy

Didn't seem particularly biased to me either. Oh though you might have mentioned some other competitors with free search and email services...

3 days ago by MattChurchy on Time for an evil umpire: Google, Microsoft & privacy
Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe

James - exactly as much as anyone paid you for your comment; I don't feel that I need to say that I'm independant and unbiased, but just for you...

3 days ago by Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe on Time for an evil umpire: Google, Microsoft & privacy
Carl White

Once they realise symantec are willing to pay real money, they will simply keep extorting, unless of course symantec/authorities can use the...

3 days ago by Carl White via Facebook on Symantec offered hackers $50k in source code sting

Latest in Application Development

Perens: Linux could learn from Apple

Featured white papers

10 safety tips for business in 2012

Symantec.cloud

10 safety tips for business in 2012

From cloud computing to remote working, your business should consider these ways to keep your business secure as traditional IT... Read more

Deliver easy email search, storage and retrieval systems

Symantec.cloud

Deliver easy email search, storage and retrieval systems

Are you storing up trouble? There is a better way to manage corporate email storage on every level, for every size and type of... Read more

Defining your data demands in simple steps

Symantec.cloud

Defining your data demands in simple steps

Data growth provides vital resources for your business, and you can manage its enormity through some simple... Read more

Inside ZDNet UK

Cabinet Office: no lobby influence on open standards

Cabinet Office: no lobby influence on open standards

2012 Predictions: VCE FastPath, VI SAN Probe & Hadoop

2012 Predictions: VCE FastPath, VI SAN Probe & Hadoop

BlackBerry Bold 9790

BlackBerry Bold 9790

Case study: How cloud enables growth

Case study: How cloud enables growth

Ten factors that make Ubuntu 11.10 a hit

Ten factors that make Ubuntu 11.10 a hit

Toshiba Portégé Z830-10P Review

Toshiba Portégé Z830-10P Review

BT's archive: Pictures from the vault

BT's archive: Pictures from the vault