The IT chief at a London Borough which was a key battleground between Microsoft and open source has described open source software as a "red herring".
Richard Steel, chief information officer at the Borough of Newham, made the comments to a large audience of senior IT professionals at London's IP'06 event on Wednesday.
Newham is cited as a critical victory by Microsoft in its battle against open source, after the Borough decided to deploy a Windows XP-based infrastructure followed a detailed evaluation of Linux.
Steel told delegates, "Open source is a bit of a red herring. It's just a piece of software at the end of the day."
Critics have suggested that Newham evaluated Linux purely to enable it to negotiate substantial financial discounts from Microsoft. It is a view which Newham IT executives dispute.
"We asked consultants to look at the desktop and server [environments]. We wanted people who would challenge the status quo," said Steel, explaining the evaluation.
"We developed some radical theories around technology refresh. And we achieved some significant savings. We are pleased with our decision."
Steel is in the throes of preparing the Borough's network for the Olympic Games, which will be held in the north west of the Borough at Stratford.
Having laid a new fibre backbone with converged voice, data and CCTV and some 88 points of presence, he is now evaluating wireless technologies to connect residents and public sector buildings.
Carrying what Steel described as "fairly sophisticated services", the new Wi-Fi and WiMax network will provide connectivity outdoors and for council facilities including libraries, community centres and schools.
"We have proposed the UK's leading 21st century infrastructure, certainly in government," said Steel, who won the Public Sector CIO of the year award in the UK Technology Innovation & Growth Awards last year.
On his plans to connect the Borough using wireless, he said that the private sector had failed. "Some areas are commercially unattractive," he said. "We see it as quite critical to provide universal access."
That universal access may be extended to Olympic visitors when the games launch in six years time, depending on discussions with the event organising committees.
In the meantime Steel is firming up the backbone network and the key applications, which must be finalised by the earlier Olympic Games in Beijing in 2008.
"It's the biggest show on earth," Steel said. "I don't want to be risking new technology."
In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in
Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below
By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Membership FAQ
Update and Clarification. As has been pointed out to me by several people, the new color is "Eggplant", or "Aubergine". Uh-huh. I'll stick with...
8 minutes ago by J.A. Watson on Ubuntu 10.04 (Lucid Lynx) and the Latest Tempest @PeterI - Thanks for reading and commenting. However, I'm not sure that I understand what you are suggesting to download here, and how it would...
20 minutes ago by J.A. Watson on The Agony of Reloading Windows
@malca Define quality. I'm sure there are a few who can tell the visual difference between h264 and ogg/on2 in the lab. Probably a few more who can...
1 hour ago by GreyCells on Sting in the tail for web's video codec search
While I can see where you're coming from here, however downloading the standalone sp2 from MS isn't that difficult (It's the first hit in google...
1 hour ago by PeterI on The Agony of Reloading Windows
Adrian ZDNetUK BLOG: "Specialised Police Simulation Software Fits The Bill" http://bit.ly/biT0iU
2 hours ago on Twitter by ABridgwater ... and now for my cheesiest ever pun headline in a ZDNetUK blog
2 hours ago on Twitter by ABridgwater Why not say thanks for pointing out weaknesses and ridicule him for "ufo cover-up"? its a win win ! this is all major theater.
3 hours ago by youefou on McKinnon review court date set Having one standard would be much better but not if that one standard means lower quality video.
3 hours ago by malca on Sting in the tail for web's video codec search Hi Jake, I like your definition. I would add "Free to support, in whatever way you see fit and appropriate, or not." jw
4 hours ago by J.A. Watson on Free Software Definition condensed
From what I've read here and elsewhere Viacom stands to lose very heavily from this spat. They have already lost all public credibility since it...
6 hours ago by Tezzer on Google, Viacom trade blows in YouTube copyright spat Still finding it difficult to get around the site. Some articles/comments seem to have reply links and some don't - only a link to the poster.
6 hours ago by Tezzer on ZDNet UK: faster, smarter, still IT all the way Unfortunately the real problem here is that a very small number of very big companies want to make a great deal of money out of this. Every house...
6 hours ago by Tezzer on It's high time we had a manifesto for fibre
this spam bot is exasperating
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband :D I think the server exchange does slow down a bit round 5 to 7/8 pm but I find I mostly get 3 to 4 MBps on downloads and by that time there...
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband night before last
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband 5MBps, I saw 5.8
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband honestly I do get
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband thank you for the support. ..but in
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband if you download a BIG file from the MS site then THAT is your *true* speed.
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...Broadband Hi Fat Pop Do Wop!
10 hours ago by dava4444 on I'd Rather Have a Bigger Byte Than a Little bit...BroadbandFor multi-store outlets, including retail, banking, grocery, gas, hospitality, convenience stores and others, reducing (or avoiding) the cost of in-store system support and maintenance while maintaining compliance with PCI and other requirements has become a strategic challenge.
Speaker: Dr. Chenxi Wang, Principal Analyst, Security and Risk Management, Forrester Research, Inc. As Enterprises are increasingly connected to the Internet and as hard organizational boundaries are fast disappearing, security professionals are facing fresh challenges in Enterprise computing.
This tutorial is for new MindManager users and teaches you how to get started, by creating maps, reading maps and organizing your information.
Talkback
Richard Steel: words are cheap. Full and uncensored publication of the memorandum of understanding between Newham and Microsoft would settle this issue once and for all.
20 Oct 06 09:14 ReplyOpen Source is more than just whether or not you want to upgrade to linux. Of course it's just software, but for me it is a way of getting what you actually need from software, rather than what the vendors think you ought to buy. It puts more power in the hands of IT leaders, not more risk (although it means you have to have a more mature approach to this than a worthless and expensive support agreement with a big vendor)
20 Oct 06 09:46 ReplyComments like this confirm why public sector IT is so highly regarded and respected in the UK and elsewhere....
20 Oct 06 10:03 ReplyYes, well, he would wouldn't he. It's part of the... 'understanding' between Microsoft and Newham that Newham executives will promote Microsoft at the expense of Open Source. A fact that would be plain to all if the 'Memorandum of Understanding' was published.
20 Oct 06 11:22 ReplyThis is just business as usual, and the UK Public Sector IT will continue to be open to accusations of corruption, inefficiency, and wastage of *billions* of pounds whilst these kind of practices escape the full light of public scrutiny.
Publish the Memorandum of Understanding Mr Steele, the full, unedited one, and let the world judge for itself the sincerity of these statements.
Prove that your comments are not just Microsoft PR regurgitated as part of an... understanding.
"It's the biggest show on earth," Steel said. "I don't want to be risking new technology."
20 Oct 06 14:43 ReplyThis statement sums up the whole argument and proves that this was stunt for a Microsoft discount. Steel went into the evaluation with his mind already made up. He didn't want to take a risk.
But who could blame him? Linux is about 4 years off from being mainstream.
all fighting over which is best aside. It is a case of open source is just another piece of software...
23 Oct 06 14:20 ReplyOne you can control if you should so wish or that you can pay somebody else to control for you.
closed source, well that only comes with one flavor we control you with it.
I'd like to see all public bodies forced to use Open source. Train our selves how to use and control software rather than be controlled by it and it's creators.
BTW I do like the many good things that microsoft has brought the usablility of PC's. I just don't like the way they get the job done or cost they charge for it.