The Conservative party has criticised the UK government over its lack of implementation of open-source technology.
Government departments have failed to capitalise on the software as a resource, even though reports from its agencies have looked at the feasibility of open source and recommended its use, a statement from the office of the shadow chancellor, George Osborne, said on Tuesday.
"The UK government is falling far behind," the statement said. "Too much taxpayers' money is being wasted as a result of flawed procurement, risk-adverse bureaucracy and a lack of incentives for cutting costs."
In the statement, the Conservatives released recommendations drawn up by Mark Thompson, a lecturer in information systems at Cambridge University's Judge Business School. Thompson was asked by the Conservatives in March to assess how open source could be given a "level playing field" in government IT procurement.
Thompson suggested modifying procurement processes to break major IT projects down into smaller, simpler components. This would allow smaller businesses to bid, and so increase the number of companies able to tender. He said this would stimulate open-source use in government.
"It isn't rocket science — it's about creating a modern and efficient procurement system," said Thompson in the Conservative statement. "Governments and companies around the world are making use of open-source software, and we could achieve much more here in the UK."
In their statement, the Conservatives questioned why open source is not more prominent in government departments, given that five years have elapsed since two official reports into its use were published. In 2004, the Office of Government Commerce released a report, titled "Open Source Software Trials in Government", which said that open source was "a viable and credible alternative to proprietary software". A number of reports from the British Educational Communications and Technology Agency (Becta), including one produced in 2004, have highlighted the feasibility of open-source use in schools.
Read this
Feature: Ten things you can do to help open source
Ask not what open source can do for you and your business, but what you can do for open source...
A push for open standards will also help pave the way for open source, Thompson said.
Writer and comedian Stephen Fry, a supporter of the use of open-source products, welcomed Thompson's recommendations.
"Lo, our sheep that was lost is now found," said Fry. "This is good news. Aside from anything else, [think of] the money that could be saved in government: schools, hospitals, civil service, defence, by choosing open source and free operating systems and software. It's a wave that's rolling over Europe and America, and it's only right that we in Britain should ride that wave too. I think politicians from all sides should endorse the aim for public systems to be run on free and open-source software."
The Conservatives said the recommendations by Thompson would now be considered by the Shadow Treasury team for inclusion in party policy.
Mark Taylor, chief executive of open-source vendor Sirius, also welcomed Thompson's recommendations. "Open procurement, open standards and open source are the keys to redeeming the UK public sector's IT track record and to renewing Britain's IT industry," he said.
The Office of Government Commerce, the agency that monitors government procurement, had not responded to a request for comment on Wednesday.
Talkback
: The Office of Government Commerce,
: the agency that monitors government
: procurement, had not responded to a
: request for comment on Wednesday.
Given that other countries and even parts of the UK public sector have benefited from the use of Open Source and the UK government has published the statements cited above, there are but two reasons not to go ahead and use it in the UK, or at the very least allow the Open Source service companies a fair shake.
One involves a lack of desire to save us a bunch of money and the other involves US standard sized brown envelopes. I don't honestly know which of the two I would prefer.
Talking of brown envelopes, it was interesting to see SOCITM's immediate response to this - see http://tinyurl.com/al5vu3
SOCITM has ignored the Tory suggestion to use more Open Source software only to promote the suitability of a second-tier global IT conglomerate - Logicalis - for sub-£100m projects.
Great.
The Conservatives’ recent proposal for a £100m cap on government IT projects is grounded on an appropriate and sensible ambition to reduce the amount of money wasted on IT projects.
Reacting to the spiralling costs of the much-delayed NHS computer system, the Conservatives are right to propose that something be done. An arbitrary cap on the budget is clearly not the solution, although does reflect a global trend for smaller contracts across multiple providers. Government departments, like companies in the private sector, must take a step back and determine whether the project is actually worthwhile in the first place – and, indeed, whether they have the processes in place to manage it effectively. This is just as true of small contracts – especially where multiple providers are involved.
The most effective way to eliminate wasteful expenditure on IT projects is to maximise the value of what has already been bought and paid for. Ripping out systems without understanding where existing ‘value add’ might lie is a reckless use of IT resources, whether outsourced or in-house.
The government must think carefully about whether a completely new system delivers the value they need before committing to expensive projects.