Judge slams door on Napster

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

NEWS
A federal judge on Wednesday issued a surprise injunction requiring Napster to block all copyrighted music on its site. The injunction will go into effect midnight Friday, local time. The recording industry must pay a $5m bond against any financial losses Napster might suffer by being shut down pending trial. Saying the recording industry is likely to prevail in its copyright infringement case against the popular song-sharing company, US district judge Marilyn Patel's ruling could, in effect, shut down the free music swapping service. Patel ruled unexpectedly from the bench immediately after a two-hour hearing, telling a packed courtroom her order would keep Napster from "copying or assisting or enabling or contributing to the copy or duplication of all copyrighted songs and musical compositions of which the plaintiffs hold rights". The Recording Industry Association of America filed a lawsuit in December, just five months after Napster's launch, saying the company's song-sharing service promotes copyright infringement. The case is scheduled for trial later this year. Patel denied a motion by Napster attorney David Boies, which asked her to delay the order. Outside the courtroom, Boies vowed an appeal and, separately, Napster executives said the company would file papers Thursday morning. Boies said the order was "impossible to implement or obey" since Napster has not received a list of songs it is required to block. And, while Patel's order stopped short of pulling the plug, Boies said the injunction could cripple the business. "Between now and the actual trial, Napster's service obviously is going to be seriously curtailed [if the injunction isn't lifted]" , Boies said, adding that a settlement, though possible, was unlikely. RIAA general counsel Cary Sherman applauded the order, saying that it laid the groundwork for legal music downloads and that it could send a message to other song-swapping firms. In issuing the order, Patel denied virtually every defence claim by Napster. The RIAA recently sued another file sharing company, Scour, on similar grounds. "Our hope is that the court's decision, which is very, very clear, and very, very strong, will send a very clear signal to all those other companies," Sherman said. She said swapping songs with Napster wasn't protected under the Audio Home Recording Act, as the defence had argued, in part because it involved so many people. She added that evidence so far in the case, including internal Napster memos, had convinced her that most people used the service primarily to download copyrighted materials. Patel bought the recording industry's argument that Napster resisted complying with federal law by failing to pay royalties to copyright owners. Recording industry attorney Russell Frackman told the judge that 20 million songs were downloaded daily, of which roughly 90 percent were copyrighted. He said that Napster planned to have a user base of 75 million users by the end of the year. "The record companies not only get no return on their investment, but Napster is piggy-backing," Frackman said, adding that reining in the company would only become more difficult in the future. "The longer this goes on, your honour, the more impossible it will be for us and the court to do anything realistic," he continued, asking her to "nip this in the bud". He also said studies showing that CD sales were rising even as Napster gained momentum were "weak" and "irrelevant". At some points Patel was clearly irritated at Napster attorneys, challenging many of their assertions and asking them many more questions than she had asked the recording industry attorneys. After reading internal Napster planning documents related to the case. "Pirating be damned is pretty much the sense one gets," she said. "Free music for the people!" she quipped, prompting chuckles in the courtroom. Later, Patel abruptly ended Napster's presentation after an exasperated Napster attorney, Daniel Johnson, told her "you're not listening". "You may have a seat," Patel shot back. And he did. After her ruling, Patel gave both sides a chance to respond. Boies asked Patel directly if she intended to close Napster down. "I'm not ordering them to shut their business down. I want to make that clear," Patel said. During the hearing, Patel seemed not to understand that Napster was not the only site that allowed users to download free music. When Napster attorneys pointed out that people could swap songs through other -- though decidedly less popular -- means, such as chat rooms and Gnutella, Patel challenged them, saying "but you have to pay". At one point, Patel asked Johnson, "What about Gnutella, do you have to pay?" Johnson told her she did not. On Wednesday evening, company founder Shawn Fanning and chief exec Hank Barry held a brief Webcast to address user concerns. "We will keep fighting for Napster and your right to share music over the Internet," Fanning said. Barry said the company would work through the night on a solution to an injunction he said could shut the service down in its current form. "Although we sharply and firmly disagree with the judge's decision, we understand the basis for it and we plan to comply." David Coursey reckons at the end of the day, history will judge that Napster wasn't an advocate of "the Internet should be free" but a greedy bunch of corporate raiders trying to make their fortune off the property of others. Go to AnchorDesk UK for the news comment. What are your thoughts on the Napster ruling? Will you say good bye with a tear in your eye, or simply think 'good riddance'. Go to the online forums and have your say. Take me to the MP3 Special What do you think? Tell the Mailroom. And read what others have said.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

Jack Schofield

@openhgs Windows users have had multiple desktops since Linus started writing Linux. They just haven't shipped as standard because not enough...

10 hours ago by Jack Schofield on Windows 8 could speed multi-monitor uptake
Jack Schofield

@Phil at Cloud4 What, Microsoft gets £1,200 per PC and £1,622 per server? Gosh, I'm amazed....

11 hours ago by Jack Schofield on 6 million wasted licences and £1,200 PCs: welcome to government IT
craigsc

You guys have no idea what is going on at Autonomy. Autonomy could have been a much more profitable organization. The sales operations at Autonomy...

12 hours ago by craigsc on HP cuts 27,000 staff as Autonomy chief Lynch leaves
Moley

How does this impact on dual or multi booting? Seems to me to more or less prohibit this, from Windows 8 anyway. Will Grub 2 recognise Windows 8,...

12 hours ago by Moley on Windows 8 start-up speed forces USB boot workaround
apexwm

I don't understand why there cannot be a slight pause during the boot process so the user can press a key. Many operating systems do this, even if...

14 hours ago by apexwm on Windows 8 start-up speed forces USB boot workaround
Gavin Goodman

You can now buy the Xi3 modular computer in the UK at http://www.ocdistribution.com . This can be bought with the Tand3m software, pricing and...

14 hours ago by Gavin Goodman on CES 2012: Xi3 microSERV3R
Phil at Cloud4

I agree: Mike Lynch can clearly build a business and manage strategy. I suspect the exit of Mike is more likely the end of a planned handover...

17 hours ago by Phil at Cloud4 on HP cuts 27,000 staff as Autonomy chief Lynch leaves
Phil at Cloud4

This is unbeleivable government wastage with only one winner... Microsoft 1 - Tax payer Nil!

18 hours ago by Phil at Cloud4 on 6 million wasted licences and £1,200 PCs: welcome to government IT
Mispam

So what do you do when you can't boot into windows? Why can't I just hold Shift while I power up instead of having to boot into windows and click a...

18 hours ago by Mispam on Windows 8 start-up speed forces USB boot workaround
apexwm

I've also seen that Mac OS X for Intel machines is supposed to run in VirtualBox, which would also be a nice solution. I've never tried it though.

20 hours ago by apexwm on xTreme Triple Booting: Linux, Mac & Windows
dave heasman

What I wonder is why when companies are caught bang to rights in not providing contracted services, people bend over to smear the customers? Surely...

20 hours ago by dave heasman on Virgin throttles broadband for high-speed customers
pjc158

Strange statement from HP regarding Mike Lynch and not capable of scaling a company. Autonomy was a $7bn purchase which started as a small company...

21 hours ago by pjc158 on HP cuts 27,000 staff as Autonomy chief Lynch leaves
lojolondon

Or - possibly, they will destroy business by ensuring people do not invest where there is no return. Another socialist idea, well beyond it's...

24 hours ago by lojolondon on Open Data Institute will act as biz incubator
J.A. Watson

Good stuff Jake, very interesting. Thanks. jw

1 day ago by J.A. Watson on xTreme Triple Booting: Linux, Mac & Windows
openhgs

"the cost of a second LCD screen is about the same as one day of an office worker's time, so this should soon be recouped in extra productivity."...

1 day ago by openhgs on Windows 8 could speed multi-monitor uptake
Thomas Gellhaus

I also installed the KDE version; I also will probably try out razorqt since I really haven't had a chance to before. I'm looking forward to the...

1 day ago by Thomas Gellhaus via Facebook on Mageia 2 Released
francisabigail

Acquiring when reinvention/cannibalization is too challenging for a large organization can be an excellent strategy- still, so many mergers stumble...

2 days ago by francisabigail on Ariba buy parks SAP on Oracle's cloud turf
apexwm

All of the feedback regarding using a touch monitor for a desktop PC is right on. Several months ago, we installed a "demo" multitouch all-in-one...

2 days ago by apexwm on Windows 8 could speed multi-monitor uptake
191706

anyone wanting to triple boot *their* own Mac

2 days ago by 191706 on xTreme Triple Booting: Linux, Mac & Windows
SoapyTablet

Cont.. Biggest Bugbear: Win7's stop-animate-go approach to work, you develop a staggered (not in the above alchohol sense of the word) approach to...

2 days ago by SoapyTablet on Windows 8 could speed multi-monitor uptake