Is the world ready for the self-aware robot?

Q&A

What does it take for robots to be like us, to make a robot that functions like a human being?
I think the robot would have to have the capability to interact, to form meaningful relationships and to understand the value of those relationships, to understand the difference between me and other, to have empathy. Those would be the things I would describe as most crucial, and I do believe that we can build something like that. But I also do believe that if we cannot build it already ready-made, we have to build them in the way that they, like human babies, go through a process of social learning, and probably for the first critter to be built, that social process will take years and years and years, much longer than for a human baby.

At MIT, there were the robots Cog and Kismet that you wrote about in your book. Were they a first step in robots learning what it is to be like a person?
I think they were. The whole ideology behind those robots was not 'we can rebuild grown-up intelligence', but it was an acknowledgment of the fact that babies — even though obviously they are not born as blank slates, they don't have self-awareness, they don't have intentionality, they don't have all those things that we consider part of being intelligent — but they get all those capabilities through interaction with their caregivers. And so Cog and Kismet were really the first robotic models that were built in analogy to a human and learn through interaction, and I thought that was a very, very powerful approach.

The problem was, it is so hard to do it... I think what the robots could do is fascinating, but the underlying technology, as novel and as wonderful as it is, is still kind of primitive [compared to popular notions of what robots can do].

I think that for a lot of people the only thing they know about robots is what they see in the movies, whether it's "I, Robot" or R2-D2 and C-3PO, the Terminator, things like that.
And so compared to that obviously Cog and Kismet are hideously primitive. People don't know how difficult it is to build those critters, and this is why I concentrated more on our reaction toward those robots, because I thought this is a more interesting thing — for instance, the fact that Kismet really didn't learn. I think there is much more ground to build on, I think that particular research at MIT suffered from a general problem in science, and that is that highly expensive basic research is not very well funded, especially in engineering where it's so expensive to build that stuff — there always needs to be an application.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in

Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Membership FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

apexwm

Fedora is the same way as well. The yum update system uses "presto" which shrinks the amount of data needed for download. It's a great system....

1 hour ago by apexwm on Can you believe it - 2765 kB will be freed?
cybfor

Updated ID cards considered for 2012: [zdnet.co.uk] The government is considering introducing a new generation of ID... http://dlvr.it/KpBZ

cybfor

Google, Viacom trade blows in YouTube copyright spat: [zdnet.co.uk] Google and the US media giant Viacom have issued... http://dlvr.it/Knht

CIMITL

Be sure to include an audio option - eg. a beep tone - to intensify and reiterate the action. This will greatly benefit some consumers and give...

3 hours ago by CIMITL
DataSecurityUK

Data disposal is really important to get right. There are standards set by UK and US federal governments to ensure that data is kept secure. If...

3 hours ago by DataSecurityUK
chaycon1

Online Fiber Optic Certification Join a talented group of professionals, who are dedicated to Fiber Optic Networking technology. The online course...

5 hours ago by chaycon1 on BT launches 40Mbps fibre-based broadband
chaycon1

Online Fiber Optic Certification Join a talented group of professionals, who are dedicated to Fiber Optic Networking technology. The online course...

5 hours ago by chaycon1 on Google to build gigabit broadband to the home
J.A. Watson

Hi Dava, I'm glad to hear from you, and glad that you see things from the other side. I think that is the most important point of the whole...

6 hours ago by J.A. Watson on Ubuntu 10.04 (Lucid Lynx) and the Latest Tempest
dava4444

please please please please please please kill that spam bot.

6 hours ago by dava4444 on ZDNet UK: faster, smarter, still IT all the way
253chelisa253

hi

7 hours ago by 253chelisa253 on How security will look in 10 years
lezlow

it is only greedy[microsoft]?

8 hours ago by lezlow on Researchers break into BitLocker
dava4444

it didn't post the link it's 'Ubuntu 10.04 Lucid Lynx Beta-1 First Look' on youtube :) Dava

9 hours ago by dava4444 on Ubuntu 10.04 (Lucid Lynx) and the Latest Tempest
dava4444

Hi James I disagree, Ubuntu needs a GUI update and this one IMO is quite good. your pics show a low res. here's a high res. on YouTube* The...

9 hours ago by dava4444 on Ubuntu 10.04 (Lucid Lynx) and the Latest Tempest
dava4444

Hi any news on the comment bot? knocking me back from my own blog is a bit cheeky lol *Mulder to Scully* "I think it has an agenda.." I know, I...

10 hours ago by dava4444 on ZDNet UK: faster, smarter, still IT all the way
benny boy

if you look at the Brentwood exchange on samknows it servers 21,000 residential propertiesm, Lowestoft serves 31,000! Come on BT sort yourselves...

10 hours ago by benny boy on BT fibre broadband coming to 69 more towns
pbreddit

[programming] H.264 - a sting in the tail http://reddit.com/bfu4q [zdnet.co.uk]

reddit

H.264 - a sting in the tail [programming] 13 points, submitted by zigzag [zdnet.co.uk] http://reddit.com/bfu4q

cybfor

Malware infects second Vodafone HTC phone: [zdnet.co.uk] A second Android-based HTC Magic from Vodafone has been... http://dlvr.it/KhKx

miyabi81

Chatter preview http://www.zdnet.co.uk/news/application-development/2010/03/17/salesforce-opens-up-chatter-developer-preview-40088348/

cybfor

US gov t considers undercover social networking: [zdnet.co.uk] The Obama administration has considered sending... http://dlvr.it/Kh3L

Featured white papers

Achieving PCI Compliance for:Privileged Password Management & Remote Vendor Access

For multi-store outlets, including retail, banking, grocery, gas, hospitality, convenience stores and others, reducing (or avoiding) the cost of in-store system support and maintenance while maintaining compliance with PCI and other requirements has become a strategic challenge.

Download now

Web 2.0 Security Threats: How to Protect Your Enterprise Network

Speaker: Dr. Chenxi Wang, Principal Analyst, Security and Risk Management, Forrester Research, Inc. As Enterprises are increasingly connected to the Internet and as hard organizational boundaries are fast disappearing, security professionals are facing fresh challenges in Enterprise computing.

Download now

MindManager - Tutorial for New Users - Short

This tutorial is for new MindManager users and teaches you how to get started, by creating maps, reading maps and organizing your information.

Download now