Judge puts file swappers in hot seat

By Lisa M Bowman, GameSpot Europe, 5 March, 2002 10:50

NEWS

A federal judge on Monday ordered a trio of popular file-swapping services to stand trial on copyright infringement charges, ending a bid to bring a quick end to their legal troubles with the entertainment industry. Attorneys for defendants Kazaa, StreamCast Networks and Grokster had hoped to convince the judge that their products demonstrated sufficient legitimate uses to qualify for the "Betamax defense" -- a copyright safe harbour set by the US Supreme Court in the 1980s that cleared the way for home videotape recorders. Instead, Judge Stephen Wilson said a jury would hear the first phase of the case, which would focus on whether defendants StreamCast, Kazaa and Grokster allowed the pirating of movies and music. Later, the owners of the copyrights could try to widen the scope of the case and seek damages, Wilson said. In issuing the ruling, Wilson sided with the entertainment industry's request for a trial schedule and called the defendant's motion for summary judgment premature. "You've jumped the gun," Wilson told defense attorneys, who had hoped the judge would narrow the case. The closely watched case is a successor to the entertainment industry's suit against Napster, and is important because it raises key questions about the legality of new networks that have sprung up that allow people to trade movies and music. The peer-to-peer networks in this case may be harder to control than Napster because people don't have to connect to central servers to trade files -- meaning companies have no mechanism to control the activities of their customers. However, recent glitches in the software have raised questions about how much control the companies really have over their networks. Music companies and movie studios sued StreamCast, Kazaa and Grokster in October, making much the same argument they did in the Napster case: The companies are promoting theft of their copyrighted works by providing the means for rampant file sharing. Before hearing from the attorneys, the judge joked that he had tried the software. "It works. I got some nice music," he quipped, adding, "There are all sorts of opportunities out there" for using the software. However, Wilson quickly adopted a no-nonsense approach to the hearing, giving each side a few minutes to argue for and against summary judgment. Andrew Bridges, an attorney with Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati who argued for StreamCast, asked the judge to consider that the file-sharing software used by StreamCast had non-infringing uses -- a possibility that could protect it against the plaintiff's charges. He said the entertainment industry was merely trying to quash the software in an effort to exert undue control over its material. "Plaintiffs do want to stop distribution of the software," he said. "It's clear that they want to do that." However, David Kendall, who argued for the plaintiffs, said the Napster case paved the way for this suit. He said the case must decide how much the defendants know about what's being done on their systems. "We are not opposed to peer-to-peer technology," said Kendall, of Washington, DC-based Williams & Connolly. However, he said, the plaintiffs were using the technology to run a "cybernetic Alice's restaurant, and the menu is our protected content." Kendall said his clients were seeking to shut down the software in the form of an injunction while the case is decided. After Wilson ruled on the trial date, Keker & Van Nest's Michael Page, who was representing Grokster, argued that allowing the plaintiffs to eventually broaden the case would be unfair. "They want to come in with a tiny baby and throw out all the bath water with it," he said. StreamCast, Kazaa and Grokster have all licensed FastTrack file-swapping software to allow users to trade works over a loose network of computers. StreamCast's Morpheus software has been among the most popular software of this type. Lawyers for StreamCast, including attorneys for technology civil liberties group the Electronic Frontier Foundation, argue the case is markedly different from Napster. For one, distributors of FastTrack-based software don't have a central indexing system, as Napster did, making it much more difficult to control the files their users swap. Legal experts said defense attorneys must convince the judge that services like StreamCast's have "substantial non-infringing uses," a legal notion that protected makers of the home video recorder in the mid-80s. In that case, lawyers for the entertainment industry argued that the Betamax recorder would lead to widespread piracy. However, Betamax prevailed after the US Supreme Court ruled that the recorders could be used in ways that did not violate copyrights. What's more, they argued in papers asking for summary judgment, StreamCast and its cohorts are no more responsible for illegal activity on their networks than America Online or Microsoft's MSN Internet service would be. The lawyers say the suit is just one more attempt by copyright holders to control the development of new technology. "It is precisely this radical view, that copyright law somehow conveys a veto power over technology, that the Supreme Court rejected in the Sony-Betamax case," attorneys for StreamCast wrote. Evoking statements they made repeatedly in the Napster case, entertainment industry lawyers have said the file-swapping network that allows people to trade a variety of works was designed specifically for illegal use. Lawyers for Kazaa, StreamCast and Grokster can appeal Wilson's ruling.

See the MP3 News Section for the latest on everything from MP3 players to Napster and the other music swapping services. Have your say instantly, and see what others have said. Go to the Napster Debate. Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

@Jack, > Works really well for thieves.... Nice attempt to deflect the argument by tossing in a point that's totally irrelevant, even it were...

1 hour ago by BrownieBoy on AMD Ultrathins to challenge Intel Ultrabooks

Make that 13 people now - I got refused today at Manchester airport. I thought I was up to date on this legislation - I knew of the EU ruling from...

4 hours ago by bootlegger on UK airport body scans will not be opt out

Don't forget to check out apps like GoodReader or SlideShark either, they're indispensible for people on the go in presentation situations. Best...

7 hours ago by tinycg on Four top iPad apps for people on the move

Well it seems there is something a number of us agree on. Why is the Ubuntu Unity launcher so ugly? I thought perhaps it was something to do with...

11 hours ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Duplicate comments are not made intentionally. Its very good to know that now you are keeping check on this problem because sometimes a commenter...

21 hours ago by Freebies202 on Microsoft fixes blog comments, speeds up blogs with open source

"the very significant number of users" and "many (most) of us" - you have no evidence for these statements. It is a fact that most users are saying...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Another grammar faux pas is the improper use of "you". When sitting down down in a restaurant, for example, I get cringe when the waitress...

1 day ago by Marg Menzies Harrison via Facebook on 10 flagrant grammar mistakes that make you look stupid

And NOW, folks, for Canonical's next trick... Kubuntu is late. Here's a pencil. Draw your own conclusions. cf.:...

1 day ago by zdnetukuser on Linux Minterface

@kevinmchapman. The discussion here reflects the very significant number of users who really do like the traditional menu system and who wish to...

1 day ago by Moley on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Er, no... It is an efficient means of finding the application/file/setting you need in one place. The icons are a simply a fallback for when you...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Isn't the provision of a text based search an admission by the developers that the mass of icons approach does not work? I don't need to use a...

1 day ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

"Unity and GNOME 3 both abandon the old text-based cascading menus in favour of a graphical icon-driven system." Point truly missed. Both use a...

2 days ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

whs001 - Thank you, I'm glad you liked the article. I absolutely agree with you on your first point. I should perhaps have made it clearer that...

2 days ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

If we allow corporate interest to dictate the way our government circumvents due process against foreign entities then we should accept the same...

2 days ago by Dennis Nilsson via Facebook on ACTA stumbles in Germany

I totally dislike pirating of works, I fear that artists will be deterred from creating works if they think that they are going to get ripped off....

2 days ago by GHar123 on ACTA stumbles in Germany

How dare film makers, artists or anybody that invests in creativity stop us pirating their works for free. I want to be able to walk into my local...

2 days ago by JCB33 on ACTA stumbles in Germany

@GrueMaster. I prefer horses for courses rather than one size fits all. I, and I suspect most other computer users, do not really wish to have...

2 days ago by Moley on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

The product that scares me every time I have to use it is the Office 2007 version of Excel. The first bug that I found was applying the median...

2 days ago by greycynic on Ten flawed products that derail productivity

Nice review and very informative. One thing I'd like to add (in reply to whs001's 1st question), the main reason to have the same interface from...

2 days ago by GrueMaster on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

I'be been using Mint 12 since the RC came out, and I am far more happy with the Cinnamon, the Mate, and, yes (with extensions), theGnome 3...

2 days ago by Frederick Wrigley via Facebook on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Featured white papers

Latest jobs

Judge puts file swappers in hot seat

Daily Newsletters

Topics

Related stories

Kazaa plays on despite threat of fines

Kazaa halts software downloads

Morpheus network goes open source

Heart of England NHS begins massive digitisation plan

Hard-drive woes hit PC shipments in fourth quarter

Post your comment

ZDNet UK Live

Latest in IT Strategy

Heart of England NHS begins massive digitisation plan

Hard-drive woes hit PC shipments in fourth quarter

Featured white papers

Latest jobs

PHP Web Developer - html, css, javascript

Java Developer, Online Gaming, London

Quant Dev, Hedge Fund, FX, Excel VBA

Inside ZDNet UK

A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

2012 Predictions: VCE FastPath, VI SAN Probe & Hadoop

BlackBerry Bold 9790

Make faster, smarter decisions using BI

Ten factors that make Ubuntu 11.10 a hit

Toshiba Portégé Z830-10P Review

BT's archive: Pictures from the vault

News & Analysis

Reviews

Blogs

Resources

About Us

Member Services

Special Features

Advertising Features

ZDNet UK / News and Analysis / Business of IT / IT Strategy

Judge puts file swappers in hot seat

Daily Newsletters

Topics

Related stories

Post your comment

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

Latest in IT Strategy

Featured white papers

Latest jobs

Inside ZDNet UK

Resources

About Us

Member Services

Special Features

Advertising Features