HP criticises printer ink rival for DMCA suit

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

NEWS
A top Hewlett-Packard printer executive said that although intellectual property rights are vital in the printer industry, rival Lexmark is wrong to try and use a controversial copyright law to safeguard those rights. In an interview with CNET News.com, HP senior vice president Pradeep Jotwani said Lexmark is using the 1998 Digital Millennium Copyright Act in ways it was not intended, in pursuing a lawsuit against a maker of remanufactured toner cartridges. "We think it is stretching it," Jotwani said of the Lexmark suit, which was filed on 30 December against Static Control Components, a maker of remanufactured toner cartridges. "The DMCA was put in place (to protect) things like movies, music and software applications." Jotwani said HP will protect its intellectual property rights if companies infringe on them, but the DMCA is not the right weapon to use. A Lexmark representative declined to comment specifically on Jotwani's remarks. "I don't plan on going down that path," Jotwani said, referring to using the DMCA. HP did threaten last year to use the copyright law to pursue a team of researchers who demonstrated a bug in its Tru64 Unix operating system. However, the company later backed down. The issue is a critical one for HP, Lexmark and nearly all printer makers. Ink is the lifeblood of the industry, with supplies accounting for the bulk of profits. In HP's case, its printing and imaging business makes more money than the company as a whole, with much of the profits coming from its supplies business, which Jotwani heads. Jotwani said that although HP thinks its own supplies deliver the best quality and value for most customers, he believes there should be a place for those companies that sell refilled cartridges and refill kits. "I think customers draw the line. Part of that choice is they can choose our original supplies, which is always what we'd like them to do. But there is a segment of the market that is cost-conscious that draws a different line." Jotwani said that HP makes its inkjet cartridges refillable, although on some models some high-end features, such as ink-level monitoring, are disabled once a cartridge is refilled. "We consciously make sure that our cartridges are reusable and refillable," Jotwani said. The company does put some limits on the practice, such as adding software that makes some of its cartridges unusable after a certain expiration date -- either four-and-a-half years after manufacture or two-and-a-half years after a cartridge is installed. Gary Peterson, who covers the inkjet-printing arena for market researcher ARS, said that HP makes refilling technically feasible, but still tries to discourage consumers in other ways. "It is easy to refill HP cartridges," he said. "They do allow that to happen." However, Peterson said HP has done other things, such as suing manufacturers for patent infringement and trying to keep refilled cartridges off the shelves of well-known stores. "They put as much heat as possible on retailers" not to carry remanufactured cartridges, Peterson said. HP has also made moves that make it more desirable for consumers to get a new cartridge, such as moving the print nozzles onto the cartridge. Those nozzles can get blocked or fire less accurately after a period of time, Jotwani said. "What we have tried to do is, the stuff that lasts for a long time we put in the printer," he said. "The stuff we have to change, we put in the consumable." Bill Gott, who edits the industry newsletter Printer Market Monitor, said Lexmark has a right to defend its intellectual property through the courts. He noted that HP has done so many times in the past. "I think it's reasonable to expect any of the vendors to protect their work," he said.
See the Digital Rights News Section for the latest on DVD-Ram, DVD-RW, zoning and copy protection. Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.

Talkback

I am a retailer of remanufactured cartridges, and i must say that HP is doing what is best for all. I mean come on, isn't it best when you have a choice. That's what makes our great market so great. Look at the after-market car part industry, imagine if you had to buy products from only your local GM dealer. Most would, but believe it or not, some do prefer another simular part for their car. Sure the GM OEM part always costs more because of strict factory standards, but imagine not having a choice between the two as a consumer. By allowing an aftermarket product, HP is allowing consumers to have that choice. We should commend HP for its broad sense of vision and applaud them for demonstrating that corporations can think beyond the box.

via Facebook 3 October, 2003 09:52
Reply

I agree. The consumer should at least get a choice. I have a Canon printer and I have purchased ink from places like Staples and payed for the OEM ink, but I have also purchased ink online. The last ink I bought was from http://www.inkreplacement.com/InkCartridges and I found that it works just as good as the OEM ink. So I appreciate having a choice.

via Facebook 22 September, 2006 18:37
Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

TerryRK

Well it seems there is something a number of us agree on. Why is the Ubuntu Unity launcher so ugly? I thought perhaps it was something to do with...

3 hours ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
Freebies202

Duplicate comments are not made intentionally. Its very good to know that now you are keeping check on this problem because sometimes a commenter...

13 hours ago by Freebies202 on Microsoft fixes blog comments, speeds up blogs with open source
kevinmchapman

"the very significant number of users" and "many (most) of us" - you have no evidence for these statements. It is a fact that most users are saying...

21 hours ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
Marg Menzies Harrison

Another grammar faux pas is the improper use of "you". When sitting down down in a restaurant, for example, I get cringe when the waitress...

22 hours ago by Marg Menzies Harrison via Facebook on 10 flagrant grammar mistakes that make you look stupid
zdnetukuser

And NOW, folks, for Canonical's next trick... Kubuntu is late. Here's a pencil. Draw your own conclusions. cf.:...

23 hours ago by zdnetukuser on Linux Minterface
Moley

@kevinmchapman. The discussion here reflects the very significant number of users who really do like the traditional menu system and who wish to...

1 day ago by Moley on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
kevinmchapman

Er, no... It is an efficient means of finding the application/file/setting you need in one place. The icons are a simply a fallback for when you...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
TerryRK

Isn't the provision of a text based search an admission by the developers that the mass of icons approach does not work? I don't need to use a...

1 day ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
kevinmchapman

"Unity and GNOME 3 both abandon the old text-based cascading menus in favour of a graphical icon-driven system." Point truly missed. Both use a...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
TerryRK

whs001 - Thank you, I'm glad you liked the article. I absolutely agree with you on your first point. I should perhaps have made it clearer that...

1 day ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
Dennis Nilsson

If we allow corporate interest to dictate the way our government circumvents due process against foreign entities then we should accept the same...

1 day ago by Dennis Nilsson via Facebook on ACTA stumbles in Germany
GHar123

I totally dislike pirating of works, I fear that artists will be deterred from creating works if they think that they are going to get ripped off....

1 day ago by GHar123 on ACTA stumbles in Germany
JCB33

How dare film makers, artists or anybody that invests in creativity stop us pirating their works for free. I want to be able to walk into my local...

2 days ago by JCB33 on ACTA stumbles in Germany
Moley

@GrueMaster. I prefer horses for courses rather than one size fits all. I, and I suspect most other computer users, do not really wish to have...

2 days ago by Moley on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
greycynic

The product that scares me every time I have to use it is the Office 2007 version of Excel. The first bug that I found was applying the median...

2 days ago by greycynic on Ten flawed products that derail productivity
GrueMaster

Nice review and very informative. One thing I'd like to add (in reply to whs001's 1st question), the main reason to have the same interface from...

2 days ago by GrueMaster on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
Frederick Wrigley

I'be been using Mint 12 since the RC came out, and I am far more happy with the Cinnamon, the Mate, and, yes (with extensions), theGnome 3...

2 days ago by Frederick Wrigley via Facebook on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
bdantas

Excellent article. One small correction, though--although a fresh installation of Linux Mint 12 will, indeed, provide the user with a version of...

2 days ago by bdantas on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint
Alan Ralph

In related news, the ISPs club together to get the members of the Home Affairs Select Committee (ya goofed on that part, ZDNet UK) copies of "The...

2 days ago by Alan Ralph via Facebook on MPs urge ISPs to take down terrorist material
Alan Ralph

In related news, the ISPs club together to get the members of the Home Affairs Select Committee (ya goofed on that part, ZDNet UK) copies of "The...

2 days ago by Alan Ralph via Facebook on MPs urge ISPs to take down terrorist material