Arguments presented in DVD cracking case

By Lisa M Bowman, CNET News, 30 May, 2003 08:05

NEWS

California Attorney General Bill Lockyer called DVD-cracking software DeCSS a tool for "breaking, entering and stealing" during a hearing before the California Supreme Court on Thursday. "The program DeCSS is a burglary tool," Lockyer told the judges, adding that the movie studios lose millions of dollars because of piracy over the Internet. California's high court is considering whether a ban on the posting of the code, which cracks the content-scrambling system designed to protect DVD movies, violates free speech. Lockyer, who's gearing up to run for governor next year, appeared on the side of the DVD Copy Control Association, which is arguing that the posting of the code on the Net should be banned. The case, DVD CCA v. Bunner, started four years ago, when the DVD CCA sued Andrew Bunner and hundreds of other people, saying they violated California trade-secret law by displaying links to the code. A trial court in Santa Clara County, California granted an injunction banning the posting of the code, but Bunner appealed, saying the injunction violated his free speech rights. The Sixth District Court of Appeals in San Jose, California agreed with Bunner and reversed that injunction, so the DVD CCA appealed to the California Supreme Court. During Thursday's hearing, DVD CCA attorney Robert Sugarman told the seven-judge panel that the software is designed "to allow individuals to steal a trade secret and, by virtue of that, hack into a system that protects the trade secrets of motion picture makers". At one point, Judge Kathryn Werdegar asked whether DeCSS deserved a strict standard of trade-secret protection since it was already widely distributed on the Internet. Sugarman said that it did. "If that were the case, especially with... the Web, an infringer could quickly post a trade secret and then say there's no real need or purpose for relief, because it's already out there," Sugarman said. Bunner's lawyer, David Greene, told the court that the DVD CCA was trying to stop the flow of information by seeking a ban on posting the code by people who are unrelated to the case. Greene said Bunner put the code on his site after reading about it on the Slashdot discussion site and wasn't involved in creating DeCSS or originally posting the code to the Web. "To call Mr. Bunner a third party is being generous," Greene said. "He's a 100th party." Greene said the trial court, in granting the injunction, failed to consider that the ban violated Bunner's free speech rights. "We're not saying it's impossible for people to protect their trade secrets," Greene told the court, saying they just must do it within the limits of the First Amendment. The judges are expected to issue a ruling in the coming weeks or months. Federal courts have already said Web publishers who posted DeCSS violated federal copyright law, namely the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. But the DVD CCA sued Bunner and others under state trade-secret laws. In a similar case brought by the DVD CCA against one-time Purdue University student and current Texas resident Matthew Pavlovich, the same court that is hearing the Bunner case ruled that California courts did not have jurisdiction, because Pavlovich had no ties to the state. The Bunner case has attracted attention from a wide variety of free speech advocates and programmers including the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Institute of Electrical Engineers and the Computer and Communications Industry Association, which have urged the court to rule in favour of Bunner. After Thursday's hearing, Bunner told a throng of reporters that a decision against him could have dire consequences for software development in general and the open-source community in particular. "It's probably more important for other people than it is for me," said Bunner, 26, who now works as a developer for Epiphany in San Mateo, California. "If this makes it harder for people to reverse-engineer things, then it makes it more difficult to make really useful things." Many software developers depend on decryption programs like DeCSS to learn about the inner workings of certain software and to make compatible products. Bunner said he originally posted the code so that people could use it to play their DVDs on the Linux operating system, a practice that was all but impossible at the time. He said he forgot about it until the DVD CCA called him and told him he better take the code down. Bunner said he never thought that posting computer code on his Web site would put him at the centre of a high-profile legal tangle over free speech and trade secrets. "It's a little surreal," Bunner said, standing just a few feet from the attorney general while gazing at the television and radio microphones that had been thrust in front of his face.

See the Digital Rights News Section for the latest on copy protection, piracy, DVD recording and your rights online. Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

Make that 13 people now - I got refused today at Manchester airport. I thought I was up to date on this legislation - I knew of the EU ruling from...

1 hour ago by bootlegger on UK airport body scans will not be opt out

Don't forget to check out apps like GoodReader or SlideShark either, they're indispensible for people on the go in presentation situations. Best...

4 hours ago by tinycg on Four top iPad apps for people on the move

Well it seems there is something a number of us agree on. Why is the Ubuntu Unity launcher so ugly? I thought perhaps it was something to do with...

8 hours ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Duplicate comments are not made intentionally. Its very good to know that now you are keeping check on this problem because sometimes a commenter...

18 hours ago by Freebies202 on Microsoft fixes blog comments, speeds up blogs with open source

"the very significant number of users" and "many (most) of us" - you have no evidence for these statements. It is a fact that most users are saying...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Another grammar faux pas is the improper use of "you". When sitting down down in a restaurant, for example, I get cringe when the waitress...

1 day ago by Marg Menzies Harrison via Facebook on 10 flagrant grammar mistakes that make you look stupid

And NOW, folks, for Canonical's next trick... Kubuntu is late. Here's a pencil. Draw your own conclusions. cf.:...

1 day ago by zdnetukuser on Linux Minterface

@kevinmchapman. The discussion here reflects the very significant number of users who really do like the traditional menu system and who wish to...

1 day ago by Moley on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Er, no... It is an efficient means of finding the application/file/setting you need in one place. The icons are a simply a fallback for when you...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Isn't the provision of a text based search an admission by the developers that the mass of icons approach does not work? I don't need to use a...

1 day ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

"Unity and GNOME 3 both abandon the old text-based cascading menus in favour of a graphical icon-driven system." Point truly missed. Both use a...

1 day ago by kevinmchapman on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

whs001 - Thank you, I'm glad you liked the article. I absolutely agree with you on your first point. I should perhaps have made it clearer that...

1 day ago by TerryRK on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

If we allow corporate interest to dictate the way our government circumvents due process against foreign entities then we should accept the same...

1 day ago by Dennis Nilsson via Facebook on ACTA stumbles in Germany

I totally dislike pirating of works, I fear that artists will be deterred from creating works if they think that they are going to get ripped off....

2 days ago by GHar123 on ACTA stumbles in Germany

How dare film makers, artists or anybody that invests in creativity stop us pirating their works for free. I want to be able to walk into my local...

2 days ago by JCB33 on ACTA stumbles in Germany

@GrueMaster. I prefer horses for courses rather than one size fits all. I, and I suspect most other computer users, do not really wish to have...

2 days ago by Moley on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

The product that scares me every time I have to use it is the Office 2007 version of Excel. The first bug that I found was applying the median...

2 days ago by greycynic on Ten flawed products that derail productivity

Nice review and very informative. One thing I'd like to add (in reply to whs001's 1st question), the main reason to have the same interface from...

2 days ago by GrueMaster on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

I'be been using Mint 12 since the RC came out, and I am far more happy with the Cinnamon, the Mate, and, yes (with extensions), theGnome 3...

2 days ago by Frederick Wrigley via Facebook on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Excellent article. One small correction, though--although a fresh installation of Linux Mint 12 will, indeed, provide the user with a version of...

2 days ago by bdantas on A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

Featured white papers

Latest jobs

Arguments presented in DVD cracking case

Daily Newsletters

Topics

Related stories

Court blocks DVD-cracking suit

Alleged DeCSS hacker faces two years

Supreme Court backs off DVD case

Heart of England NHS begins massive digitisation plan

Hard-drive woes hit PC shipments in fourth quarter

Post your comment

ZDNet UK Live

Latest in IT Strategy

Heart of England NHS begins massive digitisation plan

Hard-drive woes hit PC shipments in fourth quarter

Featured white papers

Latest jobs

PHP Web Developer - html, css, javascript

Java Developer, Online Gaming, London

Quant Dev, Hedge Fund, FX, Excel VBA

Inside ZDNet UK

A tale of two distros: Ubuntu and Linux Mint

2012 Predictions: VCE FastPath, VI SAN Probe & Hadoop

BlackBerry Bold 9790

Make faster, smarter decisions using BI

Ten factors that make Ubuntu 11.10 a hit

Toshiba Portégé Z830-10P Review

BT's archive: Pictures from the vault

News & Analysis

Reviews

Blogs

Resources

About Us

Member Services

Special Features

Advertising Features

ZDNet UK / News and Analysis / Business of IT / IT Strategy

Arguments presented in DVD cracking case

Daily Newsletters

Topics

Related stories

Post your comment

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

Latest in IT Strategy

Featured white papers

Latest jobs

Inside ZDNet UK

Resources

About Us

Member Services

Special Features

Advertising Features