Doubts over WiMax's mobile future

Topics

WiMax, 802.16e

NEWS

WiMax is well on track to becoming an important part of the fixed broadband market, but its future in the mobile space is much less certain, according to a new report from research group Strategy Analytics.

Chris Taylor, director of Strategy Analytics's RF & Wireless Component Service, forecast that by 2009 there will be 20 million fixed WiMax installations worldwide.

There are already several examples of projects in Europe and the US which use pre-certified fixed WiMax, or 802.16d, equipment. But Taylor believes that it is the developing world where WiMax will ultimately be most popular.

"Our analysis of provisioning costs, business models and demand leads us to conclude that WiMax for fixed wireless broadband services alone will generate a modest but healthy market for chips and equipment by 2009," said Taylor.

There is particular excitement about the mobile flavour of WiMax, or 802.16e, as it could provide much faster data transfer rates than are possible with 3G today. Strategy Analytics, though, urges caution.

"Major concerns still remain regarding battery life for mobile WiMAX, undefined mobile specifications, and probable competition with 3G and proposed 4G networks," Taylor said.

Julian Grivolas of analyst group Ovum is also concerned that several issues surrounding 802.11e need to be resolved — most importantly, the final specification of the standard itself.

"Service providers, in particular incumbents, who have ambitions in mobile WiMAX are adopting a 'wait-and-see' strategy. A clarification of the 802.16e roadmap appears to be critical for the take-off of the technology for these players," said Grivolas in a research note published on Friday.

Grivolas believes that the first certified 802.16d equipment will ship late this year. He is confident that operators targeting the fixed application business will accelerate their deployment strategies once standardised indoor and outdoor solutions are available in volume and at lower price.

Talkback

The pretention by some analysts that there needs to be a 'final' version of 802.16 for mobile applications is a bit misleading. Of course the 'mobile version' of the standard needs to be voted up and accepted by the IEEE, but there won't be a 'final version' for mobility. Just as for 3GPP, technologies and standards evolve. WiMAX is a 'framework' for building out of system profiles upon the core standard. Some system profiles will define various spectrum applications and modes of operation that provide varying degrees and formats of mobility. And the 'core' standard can be expected to be updated or consolidated as task group revisions introduce new technologies and approaches.

Cellular product usage definitions are naturally simplistic: a phone or PDA someone holds in their hand defines the basic product concept. But as products incorporate increased bandwidth, larger screen formats, higher resolution video and cameras, and higher reliability of data connections, the product differentiations become more diverse and complex and entire new business use models erupt.

Part of the problem analysts let alone the public has with WiMAX is that it is by nature more capable and more broadly defined. WiMAX is more than a cell phone product definition and, for that matter, so is all the converged wireless communications/IT space. We will all have to expand the limited views developed during the narrow band wireless generation.

28 May, 2005 01:45 Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in

Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

mgibs17

Well, itâs amazing. The miracle has been done. Hatâs off. Well done, as we know that âhard work always pays offâ, after a long struggle...

6 hours ago by mgibs17 on Salesforce chief: Enterprise tech lacks innovation
mgibs17

Well, itâs amazing. The miracle has been done. Hatâs off. Well done, as we know that âhard work always pays offâ, after a long struggle...

6 hours ago by mgibs17 on Govt to review US extradition treaty
OpenSourceLinux

omg!!!! I been using read hat linux for a while sience 1998 and i recently got tire of that distor and tryed slackware 13.1.... i no longer want...

10 hours ago by OpenSourceLinux on Slackware Linux 13.1
OpenSourceLinux

omg!!!! I been using read hat linux for a while sience 1998 and i recently got tire of that distor and tryed slackware 13.1.... i no longer want...

10 hours ago by OpenSourceLinux
Tezzer

About time too!

11 hours ago by Tezzer on Govt to review US extradition treaty
Tezzer

Speaking purely from observation, I've seen only a handful of people actually using netbooks (and have one myself). None of them were running...

11 hours ago by Tezzer on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
WasteOfTime

Imagine how stupid ZDnet must feel considering it takes about 10-30 seconds to load their stupid webpage filled with ads from other sites. While...

11 hours ago by WasteOfTime on Google’s Buckyballs doodle costs people money, drives users away
SeanTheMac

Unfortunately AnAmericanFellow you seem to be in the minority. ;)

12 hours ago by SeanTheMac on Google’s Buckyballs doodle costs people money, drives users away
J.A. Watson

@manek - No, I'm saying that there are concrete statements from netbook manufacturers and REPUTABLE analysts that indicate the Linux share of the...

13 hours ago by J.A. Watson on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
apexwm

Mary : Being familiar with both Windows and Linux extensively, I would be curious to know what kinds of learning issues there were with Linux...

13 hours ago by apexwm on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
sbisson

I always thought that Wave was ideal for machines and lousy for humans...

13 hours ago by sbisson on Forcing Things Social
manek

Any news on when we'll see the putative benefits? It would be nice to see an uninterrupted data connection - even a 2G one - on a a train journey I...

13 hours ago by manek on Ofcom pumps up the volume for 3G networks
manek

So you're saying that some 25 percent of netbook buyers throw away a copy of Windows they've paid for and install Linux instead. If netbook users...

13 hours ago by manek on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
apexwm

Jamie, you bring up a good point. There hasn't been much news regarding netbooks in a while, especially on what they are running. Jack doesn't...

15 hours ago by apexwm on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
AnAmericanFellow

On behalf of all Americans, I would like to apologise for the twit that insisted on the American spelling of 'realized'. Some of us are aware of...

16 hours ago by AnAmericanFellow on Google’s Buckyballs doodle costs people money, drives users away
feaband

IE 7? It uses all that CPU just to open a tab. Really, I saw those claims, really, most of them are, simply put, just full of BS. My machine isn't...

17 hours ago by feaband
Rupert Goodwins

Mmm. Google could do with something like this. It would be brave of them - in fact, they could call it Google Brave. Or Cave. Or something like that.

17 hours ago by Rupert Goodwins on Forcing Things Social
J.A. Watson

"Linux being a disastrous failure in the netbook marketplace. (Linux went from 100% market share to less than 5%" Obviously untrue. Here is...

18 hours ago by J.A. Watson on While PC shipments will grow to a million per day, netbooks are in decline
Chris Rankin

> just want my default browser to load quickly so I can then as effortlessly as possible type > the URL I do want to go to and be done with it. In...

18 hours ago by Chris Rankin on Google’s Buckyballs doodle costs people money, drives users away
eldridgep

I always use Google as a home page for any PC I work on as I just want my default browser to load quickly so I can then as effortlessly as possible...

18 hours ago by eldridgep on Google’s Buckyballs doodle costs people money, drives users away

Featured white papers

Taking a Business Centric Approach to Service Level Compliance

Business reliance on ever more complex computer systems increases every year. These systems are at the heart of business success

Download now

Double-Take Workload Portability:X2X Sever and Storage Migration Solutions

Double-Take Move provides migration functionality that dramatically reduces the impact and risk of migrations in the data center..

Download now

The Intelligent Company White Paper

Accounting and other business systems are packed with useful, and often critical, business information which can be turned to competitive

Download now