Social-networking site Facebook has fought off a major-league blogger's bid to extract his own contact list from the service, using a utility from rival site Plaxo, highlighting the unanswered question of who owns data associated with people's identities on social-networking sites.
Facebook closed down Robert Scoble's account when it found he had used an alpha version of a "screen scraper" utility from Plaxo, to gather his 5,000 contacts' personal data, including email addresses and birthdays, for export to his Outlook and Plaxo contacts databases. The account was reinstated after Scoble, who made his name as a technical evangelist and pioneering blogger at Microsoft, agreed to stop using the utility.
Facebook has been criticised as a walled garden, for making it difficult for users to export the contact details or so-called "social graphs" they build up there, and import them to other social-networking sites. But Facebook supporters have pointed out that in this instance Scoble was breaking the service terms and conditions by attempting to use an automated tool, and by exporting personal information including phone numbers, email addresses and birthdays.
Plaxo has complained that its data importer, an unreleased feature of its Plaxo Pulse social-networking site, did nothing different from other importers, including those offered by Facebook to import data from other services, such as Google's Gmail. "For some reason Facebook has gone to inordinate lengths to prevent users from getting data out of Facebook. What's good for goose is apparently not good for gander," John McCrea, vice president of marketing at Plaxo, told ZDNet blogger Dan Farber. "We are a bit alarmed at seeing users' accounts suffer. We will evaluate the situation day-by-day, but we are still committed to user ownership and control and the portability of data," McCrea added.
Read this
How to use social networks for business gain
If managed in the right way, applications like Facebook can actually improve business collaboration...
Facebook shut Scoble's account because it made a vast number of rapid-fire accesses that looked like they could be from a spammer.
Meanwhile, security researcher Fortinet warned this week that a malicious Facebook widget called Secret Crush has been prompting users to download software that includes spyware from adware manufacturer Zango. The UK's Information Commissioner has warned users to be careful about sharing information on sites such as Facebook because they may be vulnerable to just this sort of attack.
Plaxo has been reported this week as being for sale, with suggestions that Facebook might be a likely purchaser, wanting a more business-oriented service to add to its social focus. While Plaxo is rumoured to be valued at around $200m (£100m), Facebook has topped 60 million users and is said to be worth anything up to $15bn since Microsoft bought 1.6 percent of the site for $240m.
Facebook and Plaxo were unable to respond to requests for comment before publication.
Talkback
I think i have to side with Facebook on this one; being open is one thing, what Robert Scoble tried to do is put people's private details on a social network they never chose to be a part of.
Plaxo acuses Facebook of doing the same thing, but lets look at the differences; when Facebook scrapes your google contacts, it takes the email addresses for the purpose of inviting your contacts to joint facebook, should the person decline, thats the end of the matter.
This script on the otherhand, scrapes your friends' profile pages and that is more than necessary, for example; why does it need someone's gender? why does it need your date of birth?
The question of who the data belongs to is simple, its the user who created it; this means Robert Scoble's profile belongs to him and my profile page belong to me, allowing Robert Scoble to be my friend doesn't mean am comfirtable with him taking my personal details wherever he chooses.
I'll give you a real life example; you have friends who you know their addresses, full name and dates of birth; how would they react if you signed them up for a Tesco Club card?