Mandelson backpedals on copyright law powers

NEWS

The government has proposed amendments to its own Digital Economy Bill that water down some of the more contentious aspects of the legislation.

The wide-ranging bill, currently being scrutinised by the House of Lords, is aimed partly at stemming the tide of unlawful file-sharing of copyrighted material on the internet. The amendments put forward on Tuesday by Lord Mandelson pull back on a provision to give the business secretary the power to change copyright law without consulting parliament.

This proposal has drawn the ire of Google, Facebook, eBay and Yahoo, who argue that it would allow the government to introduce "arbitrary measures" such as the "monitoring of user data even where no illegal practice has taken place".

Clause 17, the provision in question, is meant to allow the government to respond quickly to the development of new types of file-sharing technology. As it stands, the Digital Economy Bill would enable the use of a 'statutory instrument' to allow the business secretary to make law, avoiding the lengthy formal process used for bills.

Mandelson's amendments dilute the statutory instrument by introducing what is described as a 'super-affirmative procedure'. This calls for both houses of Parliament to give their approval to the business secretary's changes to law in the draft stage, while the more common type of secondary legislation enabled by statutory instrument passes by default, unless Parliament objects.

In addition, the amendments remove references to "technological developments" and make it clear that changes in copyright law must be aimed at preventing infringements that are having a "serious adverse effect" on businesses or consumers, and would have to be "proportionate" to addressing that effect.

Lord Clement-Jones, who along with fellow Liberal Democrat peer Lord Razzall has pledged to oppose Clause 17 in its entirety, said that he thought the amendments were "progress," but did not go far enough. The Liberal Democrats still intend to block the clause, he said.

"It's still process and not substance," Clement-Jones told ZDNet UK on Thursday. "They haven't changed the substance, in terms of what the clause deals with — they can still change copyright law, and that is too broad. If they want to address this, they've got to limit the scope of the clause… to the issue of illegal downloads from the internet."

Clement-Jones said the government had to be clearer about what legislative changes it thinks may be needed in the future. He also noted that the government had not previously been very responsive to technological changes, given that it is still unlawful for a consumer to rip a CD they have bought into MP3s for personal use.

"I do find this all rather strange," Clement-Jones said. "I'm all in favour of copyright protection, but we think there should be safeguards." Those safeguards should include the presumption of innocence and the need for "copper-bottomed" evidence of infringement, he added.

Mandelson also proposed changes to other clauses in the bill that have generated opposition. An amendment to Clause 11, which covers the imposition of technical measures such as bandwidth throttling and temporary account suspension, calls for such measures to be approved by both houses of Parliament.

In addition, the minister wants to tighten up the language of Clause 18, which would allow the business secretary to nationalise UK domain registries. His amendment would limit the scope to registries that deal with UK-specific domains. This follows complaints from the .tel registry, Telnic, which said it could be affected by legislation intended to tackle the .uk registry, Nominet.

Another Mandelson amendment aims to ensure that any arrangements made between copyright holders and ISPs to share the cost of enforcing copyright law would have to be approved by both houses of Parliament.

Lords Clement-Jones and Razzall also published amendments on Tuesday, including one to reduce the fine for ISPs reduced from £250,000 to £10,000. The fine would be imposed on providers that did not comply with measures to combat copyright infringement, such as sending out warning letters to suspected file-sharers.

Earlier this week, Lords Whitty (Labour) and Lucas (Conservative) tabled an amendment that would limit the scope of such measures to peer-to-peer (P2P) technology. Whitty also proposed that notifications of alleged infringement should only be sent to the accused person's postal address, not to their email address.

The next stage for the bill will be a Lords debate on Monday. Peers will then vote on the tabled amendments sometime in February, then carry out a third reading of the bill. After that, the bill will be handed over to the House of Commons.

Talkback

Its not enough by far, these amendments do nothing in protecting innocent people, infact it doesn't even deserve such a topic titleship.

CA 15 January, 2010 01:46 Reply

Proportionality is a big deal in the law, wherever it is ; domestic or EU.

I am surprised that it has taken the second reading of bill to identify this problem. Anyway better late than never?

Shibley R 15 January, 2010 14:44 Reply

These words (lyrics) from Mikado came to mind so I googled for the correct words for the chorus of 'Let the punishment fit the crime'

My object all sublime
I shall achieve in time
To let the punishment fit the crime

However, more importantly, were the serious references turned up regarding correct (proportional in current terminology) punishment. Something frequently set aside these days in the intrinsic assumption of guilt and liability in 'the one size fits all' treatment of a multitude of what used to be mainly civil matters, automatic penalties now being legislated for in ever increasing aspects of our lives.

Interesting that the correct retributive penalties prescribed by law were, recently, not applied to two prominent members of the government who had unequivocally and unambiguously broken laws of significance.

Moley 15 January, 2010 18:24 Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in

Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

nikeshoes998

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell: Find the answers in the Community FAQ free shipping wholesale product... http://bit.ly/bcjQtY

mensapparel2010

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell: Find the answers in the Community FAQ free shipping wholesale product... http://bit.ly/9GWZRh

womensapparel20

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell: Find the answers in the Community FAQ free shipping wholesale product... http://bit.ly/bPLHL8

lisabarnes001

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell: Find the answers in the Community FAQ free shipping wholesale product... http://bit.ly/bVw3F2

KC616

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell: Find the answers in the Community FAQ free shipping wholesale product... http://bit.ly/cDUyaj

KC616

free shipping wholesale products: Read more »h handbags,NIKE shoes, jewelry, watches, and jacket and so on. We gua... http://bit.ly/cWcW1e

SpyScroll

Cyberwar defence plan is essential, says former CIA head: Michael Hayden, former head of the CIA and the National ... http://bit.ly/beLpKQ

Droid_News

SAP leads businesses into augmented reality http://bit.ly/9eMWYp | #Droid #Android

wholesalegurru

free shipping wholesale products: We mainly supply top mirror quality brand name products, such as wholesale handb... http://bit.ly/cWcW1e

CNSInstructor

Cyberwar defence plan is essential, says former CIA head: Michael Hayden, former head of the CIA and the N... http://bit.ly/9sn6ax #pdln4nx

AllAboutFashion

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell http://bit.ly/9KVeqD

Droid_Phone

SAP leads businesses into augmented reality http://bit.ly/9eMWYp | #Droid #Android

AllAboutFashion

free shipping wholesale products http://bit.ly/c7cpX4

Droid_Phone

TalkTalk to sell mobile services via Vodafone deal http://bit.ly/bLVfxI | #Droid #Android

wholesalegurru

Oracle signs Solaris deals with HP and Dell: Find the answers in the Community FAQ free shipping wholesale product... http://bit.ly/cDUyaj

wholesalegurru

free shipping wholesale products: Read more »h handbags,NIKE shoes, jewelry, watches, and jacket and so on. We gua... http://bit.ly/cWcW1e

felixsprisci

DoJ joins whistleblower in Oracle fraud suit http://bit.ly/bMT3SJ

actatrudy

Update: free shipping wholesale products - ZDNet UK (... http://www.actahandbags.com/trends/free-shipping-wholesale-products-zdnet-uk-blog/

lisabarnes001

free shipping wholesale products: Read more »h handbags,NIKE shoes, jewelry, watches, and jacket and so on. We gua... http://bit.ly/bRvFgG

mensapparel2010

free shipping wholesale products: Read more »h handbags,NIKE shoes, jewelry, watches, and jacket and so on. We gua... http://bit.ly/9CXYG9

Featured white papers

The need for email archiving

Without an effective system for archiving emails, organisations can find themselves unable to recover vital business records, leaving them open..

Download now

Dell Data Storage Summary

This study was conducted in the United States amoung IT decision makers with involvement in data centre purchases at companies..

Download now

Datasheet: Infrastructure as a Service

'Infrastructure as a Service' gives enterprises the flexibility to subscribe to the compute power and storage they require today with 'pay..

Download now