Sentience: The next moral dilemma

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

NEWS
Sometime in the future machines will reach a level of intelligence that will challenge, or even surpass our own. Revered members of the academic community deem the event an inevitability. These include names like Ray Kurzweil -- inventor of the first reading machine for the blind -- Berkeley's John Searle and perhaps the man who deserves most credit for adding legitimacy to this belief, Sun Microsystems' Bill Joy. If they are right, one day man will give life to a new race of intelligent sentient beings powered by artificial means. If we can, for argument's sake, agree that this is possible we should consider how a sentient artificial being would be received by man and by society. Would it be forced to exist like its automaton predecessors who have effectively been our slaves, or would it enjoy the same rights as the humans who created it, simply because of its intellect? It is an enormous question that touches religion, politics and law, but little consideration is given to dawn of a new intelligent species and to the rights an autonomous sentient being could. For a start, it would have to convince us that it was truly sentient: intelligent and able to feel (although it is debateable whether its feelings would mirror our own). Peter Garrett, director of research and education at pro-life charity Life takes a strong stance: "I think it would take around four years of questioning before I would be satisfied that this being could be considered a person." Garrett's prudence is perhaps born of his strong religious convictions, which can weigh heavily people's thoughts about whether or not an artificial sentient being could ever hope to be seen as an autonomous person (not to be confused with becoming a human being). "I think even when we grant the label person to this new entity, it would still not be a human being... It is still a man made being and not made in the image of God... and while that may not be important on one level -- I think the secular world and the secular legal system regard it as being very unimportant -- I feel that the robot would still be a product of humanity, whereas man is believed to be a creation of God, made in the image and likeness of God," he says. This is significant because it marks a boundary around us as a species and protects us from usurpers that can never hope to be like us. Or more accurately, like God. Garrett's way of thinking is reflected when you look at why moral abuses were inflicted, for example, on black people in South Africa. Venture into the northern province of Pretoria where hundreds of thousands of Boer -- the Dutch settlers who became the fathers of apartheid -- still send their children to white only schools -- Volkskool -- and you will be told that blacks are not, like them, made in the image of God. But Garrett thinks religions would be able, in the end, to cope with the idea of a new sentient race, and that these beings would be allowed to worship: "I think the Catholic church would say: 'You are not a human being, you are not Imago Dei but you are a person and we should perhaps have a third Vatican council to discuss terms under which persons of your type can join the Catholic church. I think it might take some time and a fair bit of getting used to but I cannot see any justified reason why it could not happen." Even Buddhists, who profess to honour and respect "all sentient beings", as written in the Dharma, admit to some confusion over artificial worshippers. "Of course we believe all sentient beings have the right to live a full life with all the blessings all living creatures enjoy," a spokesman for the Buddhist Cooperative in London says. "It is a curious thing to even imagine, but we believe all that has life has the right to enjoy it to its full. I see no reason to make an exception to this new life form, although I am sure initially many eyebrows will be raised, if only out of wonder." But Garrett believes that sentient beings will never be the same as humans. "I think what we would have created would be yes a person, but not a human being and not Imago Dei. I still believe the category of human being would be very different, and one reason is that as human beings we have to move forward towards death and we have to learn how to face that. That is part of being human." In the film Bicentennial Man in which Robin Williams plays Andrew, a sentient robot who looks, feels and thinks like a human but is still classed as a droid, the death issue provides the final step toward the revered status of "human". Andrew swaps his mechanical innards for a set of organic ones that eventually age and kill him off in his sleep, earning him the posthumous award of human being. The reality of artificial beings being granted immortality through upgrades and repairs does nothing to quell the fears of those who believe robots could one day replace man as Earth's dominant species. For them at least, the question is not about whether a robot is equal to man, but rather, through its intellect and potential immortality, superior to us -- some kind of god-like race. Take me Pt II/ Legal protection and the right to choose. In ZDNet's Artificial Intelligence Special, ZDNet charts the road to sentience, examines the technologies that will take us from sci-fi to sci-fact, and asks if machines should have rights. Have your say instantly, and see what others have said. Click on the TalkBack button and go to the ZDNet News forum. Let the editors know what you think in the Mailroom. And read what others have said.

Talkback

as god made us in their image, so will we make things in our image. when this happens I believe only the qualities of the image will be apparent. Much like looking in a mirror at your own image. it looks like you, it emulates everything you do while you are in front of it, but under all circumstances it will always retain the qualities of an image and nothing more. That is why gods (while they are gods) are gods, and nothing more or less. Humans are humans, and computers are computers. It can be seen as a "fail-safe system" when dealing with the many mysteries of creation.

via Facebook 20 September, 2004 05:07
Reply

Computers are masters of illusion and every human attempt to rebuildt a computer as a human will always remain an illusion - it remains an appearance of something it is not. Time will decide whether man will master to discover the substance of his spirit and consciousness, but then he may ones again find himself standing before a galaxy of mysteries of which he has only discovered the first stars...

Claudia

via Facebook 15 June, 2006 19:26
Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

SPM

The 2 million number quoted is shipments not sales, an exact repeat of last year's dire sales of WP7. Sales to customers are likely to number only...

4 hours ago by SPM on Nokia earnings fail to shine despite Lumia
apexwm

It sounds like this is just another variable in the complex equation of Microsoft licensing, which often results in customers overpaying as it is....

5 hours ago by apexwm on UK customers to lose out in Microsoft licensing change
chonzchor

I am really thankful to you for this nice and beautiful information.I really like this. cable ties

6 hours ago by chonzchor on Currys £16.99 USB cable rip-off.
Brian Jones

What would be nice would be if Microsoft practiced consistent pricing between the US and Europe.

11 hours ago by Brian Jones via Facebook on UK customers to lose out in Microsoft licensing change
Karen Friar

@Scott Deagan: Ofcom dedicated a section to upload speeds - see page 19 onward of its full report:...

11 hours ago by Karen Friar on UK broadband speed climbs 22 percent
EUDataProtection

The EU proposals can all be read in full on the reform website: http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/minisite/index.html

13 hours ago by EUDataProtection on Firms face tough new EU fines for data breaches
Jake Rayson

Found out that Taskwarrior stores all data in plain text files: "Task writes all pending tasks to the file ~/.task/pending.data and all completed...

15 hours ago by Jake Rayson on Taskwarrior: command line task manager
ians1

"...based 6,000 miles away..." Indeed, so who do you complain to when things go wrong? I would not buy shares in Faecebook even if I could...

15 hours ago by ians1 on Facebook plans to raise $5bn via share launch
servermanagement

These are really very useful tips of backing up the system. Each tips are important and essential to prevent loosing all the data that we have....

17 hours ago by servermanagement on Ten ways to take the sting out of IT disasters
Scott Deagan

Why is the upstream never discussed? I'd like to see Ofcom explain to Internet users why people in the UK can only get a maximum of 10Mb/s upstream...

1 day ago by Scott Deagan via Facebook on UK broadband speed climbs 22 percent
Moley

Seemingly a very strange decision, even perverse. Mind you, the basis of the decision is hardly explained here or in Cnet. Perhaps we will hear...

1 day ago by Moley on Free Maps costs Google £400K in damages in France
Jake Rayson

@OccupyACAT: I had heard mention of the Emacs extension but not the Ubiquity project. Interesting to see an idea spread almost simultaneously! Re....

2 days ago by Jake Rayson on Ubuntu HUD Intenterface? Sublime already there!
markhumphryes

With no Flash support on LoveFilm, mobile devices running Android will not be able to use it - I presume - I tried a trial via my Galaxy Tab 10.1...

2 days ago by markhumphryes on Lovefilm drops Flash, kills Linux support
manek

And people wonder why there is caution about doing business with large, consumer-focused technology companies, most of which are based 6,000 miles...

2 days ago by manek on Facebook plans to raise $5bn via share launch
manek

Yes, frameworks and smarter compilers - but I suspect a lot of the code will have to be written with parallel processing as one of its fundamental...

2 days ago by manek on Parallel computing takes a step forward
Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe

Well, this is why I'm both fascinated and slightly worried; parallel computing and concurrency and complex architectures don't seem to be something...

2 days ago by Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe on Parallel computing takes a step forward
ians1

Let's hope that they take more notice of their shareholders than they do of their poor customers! I have never experienced customer service as bad...

2 days ago by ians1 on Facebook plans to raise $5bn via share launch
servermanagement

Thanks for the heads up. Will definitely check this HUD Intenterface.

2 days ago by servermanagement on Linux Minterface
Will A

Some more observations by an extremely frustrated user in Canada (apparently every country has a different set of "issues"): The web interfaces...

2 days ago by Will A on Cambridge researchers knock Verified by Visa
Jake Rayson

@zdnetukuser: I hope there's more conciliation and less bitterness in the graphical shell camps, I'd like to Ubuntu to succeed, I *want* to have a...

2 days ago by Jake Rayson on Linux Minterface