ID commissioner sees risks in IPS's two-stage IT

NEWS

Identity commissioner Sir Joseph Pilling has expressed concerns about the Identity and Passport Service's two-stage approach to its core technology.

"The IPS have gone for what they call a tactical and a strategic solution to the IT demands of running an ID scheme in this country," he told the Security Document World conference in London on 8 February. One system has been put in place for the small-scale launch of the scheme, but another will be introduced when it is expanded by forcing passport applicants to enrol.

"I am not sure whether if you have two schemes in short order you double, treble or quadruple the risk or even more than that, but I am pretty clear that it is a quite ambitious approach to take, and I am particularly intending to take an interest in the transition from the tactical to the strategic," said Sir Joseph.

Having seen the identity card enrolment process first hand, he added he was not satisfied that all the best possible standards are being applied and that he intended to keep his attention focused on this.

However, Sir Joseph said the IPS is doing a good job in looking after data. "It is not one of those bodies in the public or private sector who have shoved millions of unencrypted records out into the public domain, unintentionally, carelessly or as the victim of some malevolent member of staff or consultant," he said.

He said he will take a detached view of the scheme: "My emphasis is independence, independence and independence. But I am not only independent of the government, I am also independent of the opposition, whether they become the next government in a few weeks' time or not."

He reminded his audience of security specialists that after a general election, it could be that the UK will no longer have identity cards for British nationals. The Conservatives have pledged to scrap the scheme.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

ZDNet UK Live

Intel commoditise 50 Gb optical - remember when ethernet was an expensive add in card? Here comes the next wave... http://bit.ly/drlzkB

12 minutes ago on Twitter by bladesey

ZDNET UK: SAP leads businesses into augmented reality http://bit.ly/96kUki

12 minutes ago on Twitter by KERUFFTech

Linux Mint 9 KDE Edition Released http://bit.ly/a2dTtW http://bit.ly/aQgSYI

12 minutes ago on Twitter by opensource4life

TalkTalk to sell mobile services via Vodafone deal: Britain's largest residential ISP plans to add mobile voice an... http://bit.ly/c4oIMv

12 minutes ago on Twitter by ZDNetUK

SAP leads businesses into augmented reality: Taking a leaf out of the consumer handbook, SAP is working on augment... http://bit.ly/96kUki

12 minutes ago on Twitter by ZDNetUK

SAP leads businesses into augmented reality: ZDNet UKSAP is working on a new breed of software Ã¢Â€Â” augmented reality... http://bit.ly/8YamUZ

27 minutes ago on Twitter by TechTrend2010

Smart-meter makers embark on common standards push http://bit.ly/a9Wh2U #smart #energy

42 minutes ago on Twitter by SuzieChandler

Content Management System anyone? As more companies take control of their sites, Adobe are now getting in on the action http://bit.ly/aNnlWj

57 minutes ago on Twitter by LabLateral

Smart-meter makers embark on common standards push: Elster, Landis+Gyr and Secure said they will formulate a roadm... http://bit.ly/9HP3MD

1 hour ago on Twitter by egadgetfreak

#Cloud #News UK deems Google Wi-Fi data snatch safe: Microsoft at its financial analyst meeting ma... http://b... http://bit.ly/9sc46t #TCN

1 hour ago on Twitter by TheTechGang

Smart-meter makers embark on common standards push: The utilities metering firms Elster, Landis+Gyr and Secure say... http://bit.ly/bn5dqH

2 hours ago on Twitter by ZDNetUK_News

ZDNET UK: Smart-meter makers embark on common standards push http://bit.ly/bn5dqH

2 hours ago on Twitter by KERUFFTech

Photonic triplets hint at quantum comms three-way: By Lucy Sherriff, 30 July, 2010 14:31 News from the frontline o... http://bit.ly/cyymAG

2 hours ago on Twitter by rpreibold

UK deems Google Wi-Fi data snatch safe: ZDNET: Will a software update fix GPS and other issues with the Samsung Vi... http://bit.ly/9vHweP

2 hours ago on Twitter by SamNeace

Further to my comment above about TalkTalk (Para 3), My bank site was impossibly slow this morning, and I wondered if there was any connection to...

2 hours ago by Moley on ICO: Google Wi-Fi data contained no 'meaningful details'

What if cloud computing never matures? http://is.gd/dSJ7y

2 hours ago on Twitter by sanrau

RT @swardley: I find myself shouting "good enough bricks", I love this article by @lmacvittie - http://bit.ly/ckoS5K

3 hours ago on Twitter by GeorgeReese

I have updated my htc hero on orange to 2.1. Setting the date forward by a month gets you the first upgrade. after that you will receive the actual...

3 hours ago by sapan83 on Android 2.1 looms for Orange HTC Hero

Ah but you know that this is a topic will never die. The technologies surge and wane but the balance lies somewhere in between. And I'm too young...

3 hours ago by manek on Is tape dead?

The one thing that concerns me about "the cloud" is security. I left Microsoft software because of poor security, and I would have a very hard time...

3 hours ago by ator1940 on Open source faces hurdles in the cloud

Featured white papers