Seven in 10 government IT projects have failed, according to the chief information officer of the Department for Work and Pensions.
Joe Harley called for projects to be completed at a lower cost to the taxpayer, and said the government wanted to reduce the number of project failures to just one in 10.
Speaking at the Government UK IT Summit this week, Harley said: "Today, only 30 percent of government IT projects and programmes are successful. We want 90 percent by 2010/11. We want to achieve a 20 percent overall reduction on IT spend in government, including reducing the total cost of a government laptop by 40 percent [in the same timescale]."
Harley said that the criteria for success of a project included whether it was delivered on time, to cost, and to the quality promised. While private sector IT projects had a similar failure rate, government IT projects needed to be more efficient both in terms of cost and delivery, Harley said.
"The government spends £14bn per year on IT in the UK. It's not sustainable as a government to continue to spend at these levels. We need to up the quality while reducing the spend," Harley added.
One government project that has been heavily criticised in terms of missed deadlines and inflated costs is the troubled NHS National Programme for IT (NPfIT), which is overseen by Connecting for Health (CfH).
Andy Burn, head of information management and technology planning for CfH, said that, while the project had achieved some successes, taken as a whole, it had failed so far. "The programme still has three wheels still on. It's not in hand in some respects, but it is in others. At a local level, progress has been made over the years. At an organisational level, less [progress has been made]. The challenge is joining up services — we've been struggling with that for quite some time."
Burn added that it would take a lot of work to put NPfIT back on track. "Inevitably, with the size of the programme, we're bound to be up against the wall [for the next year]. For the next decade, not for the next year."
In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in
Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below
By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Membership FAQ
Please give me chance in the vodafone essar Ltd as back office executive
53 minutes ago by sudipta_vodafone on Vodafone culls 375 'mainly back-office' jobs I want to get a back office job in vodafone direct payroll
53 minutes ago by sudipta_vodafone on Vodafone culls 375 'mainly back-office' jobs
I also find it harder to use. It used to scale properly in Firefox. Text would size up and down without dragging all the right edge debris with it....
5 hours ago by Xwindowsjunkie on ZDNet UK: faster, smarter, still IT all the way
that comment bot is a nutter, it just referred me to the moderator on my own blog. shocked look. please help thank you Dava I'm afriad to...
8 hours ago by dava4444 on Welcome to the new ZDNet UK community! Hi Rupert! Don't think I could fill the above shoes... but if your ever looking for a consumer rights Tech blogger..tip me the wink lol peace Dava
9 hours ago by dava4444 on Fancy working for ZDNet UK? Hi Rupert My photo is gone from my profile and I just got told i was a spammer by the comment bot. the navigation is gone for my profile. :O on...
9 hours ago by dava4444 on Welcome to the new ZDNet UK community!
With windows it is always more bloat, and a lot of that seems to be duplicated in various places. I've noticed that you will have freed space on...
15 hours ago by ator1940 on Can you believe it - 2765 kB will be freed?
Buzz My Stat : New search for http://www.zdnet.co.uk Take a look: http://www.buzzmystat.com/site/zdnet.co.uk
19 hours ago on Twitter by BuzzMyStat
Hi Jamie, I'm sorry your comment got caught in the spam filter. We use an industry standard blacklist for this. I suspect that the comment may...
24 hours ago by Karen Friar on Spam? Filter Changed?
Pop - Neither have I. Ever, under any circumstances. I'm much more accustomed to Windows slowly, but inexorably, consuming more and more disk...
1 day ago by J.A. Watson on Can you believe it - 2765 kB will be freed?
Apple are currently pushing to get tv content on the iPad by April 3rd. This could possibly be seen as a spoiler for that announcement I suppose....
2 days ago by John Molloy
Hey - presume you mean something that builds on Apple's existing TV device? Apple have already had a couple of runs at building Apple TV and it's...
2 days ago by Andrew Donoghue on Google's TV timing may reveal more to come
Google, Sony, Intel may build TV project www.zdnet.co.uk/news/emerging-tech/2010/03/18/google-sony-intel-may-build-tv-project-40088359/
2 days ago on Twitter by BVE2011 70,0000 to 90,0000 computers? A very small number considering some of these botnets are in the millions, and there are so many of them operating,...
2 days ago by ator1940 on Microsoft says it decimated Waledac botnet I agree Roger, and why can't they write secure code? What will happen when they find stolen code in windows? They have a track record of...
2 days ago by ator1940 on Microsoft lashing out at Linux, open source Do you think it will really take days?
2 days ago by ator1940 on Microsoft previews Internet Explorer 9 with HTML 5 support Wonder how many days it will take before somebody codes an exploitive hack for IE9?
2 days ago by Xwindowsjunkie on Microsoft previews Internet Explorer 9 with HTML 5 support
There are some really good people in Microsoft and I wonder, how embarassing it must be for them to see how the organisation behaves from it's...
3 days ago by roger andre on Microsoft lashing out at Linux, open source On further inspection, it looks like some things are missing, is it possible that there was a time lag between whatever state the site was in that...
3 days ago by J.A. Watson on Welcome to the new ZDNet UK community!For multi-store outlets, including retail, banking, grocery, gas, hospitality, convenience stores and others, reducing (or avoiding) the cost of in-store system support and maintenance while maintaining compliance with PCI and other requirements has become a strategic challenge.
Speaker: Dr. Chenxi Wang, Principal Analyst, Security and Risk Management, Forrester Research, Inc. As Enterprises are increasingly connected to the Internet and as hard organizational boundaries are fast disappearing, security professionals are facing fresh challenges in Enterprise computing.
This tutorial is for new MindManager users and teaches you how to get started, by creating maps, reading maps and organizing your information.
Talkback
Sir,
BorlandUK 21 May 07 13:47 ReplyIt is not before time for senior government IT officials to wake up to the failure rate of public IT projects (“Seven in 10 government IT projects fail”, 17th May).
An enormous amount of money has been spent on IT projects, such as the NPfIT, that are more likely to be deemed failures than successes. The majority of problems facing public sector IT projects stem from a complete failure to plan properly prior to the implementation process. Frustratingly, it seems that failure is all too often accepted as pair for the course, when in fact it can be easily avoided. Rigorous testing prior to and during any software project can highlight problems before they become critical. Added to this, by thoroughly defining the objectives of the project at the outset, schemes can be run successfully and with fewer time delays and budget concerns.
Software development should be viewed as a managed business process, which can be successfully regulated like any other project within the business.
I very much hope that Joe Hawley’s comments lead to alert people to this issue so that the simple processes which would rectify this situation are put in place.
Yours sincerely,
Steve Gedney
MD, Borland UK
Dear Sir,
Tom Espiner 21 May 07 15:22 ReplyMany of your points are valid -- and worryingly Government seems to be moving away from rigorous planning for large-scale IT projects. The National Identity Register seems to have had no rigorous planning or testing at all, for example, with none on the horizon.
However, purely in the interests of clarity, I'd like to point out to other readers that Borland does have a commercial interest in espousing software testing, as it is an application lifecycle management company.
Also in the interests of transparency, we checked the email address linked to this ZDNet UK member, and found that it seems to be related to a PR company.
Best wishes,
Tom Espiner