Roll your own creative suite

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

BUYER'S GUIDE

So, you need to complete a design project that requires the image-editing capabilities of Photoshop along with the vectorised lines of Illustrator, and it needs to be animated in Flash with documentation in a PDF. However, your software budget is looking somewhat threadbare. Take your head out of the oven — there is a way to save your project and your wallet from the eye-watering price tags of the various versions of Adobe's Creative Suite 3 (especially in the UK). You just have to be a bit…creative.

Photoshop is arguably the most powerful and certainly the best-known of the Adobe lineup. In fact, the term 'photoshop' is now in common usage as a verb that describes altering an image. The program’s popularity is well-deserved, with an array of features that is mind-boggling. Unfortunately, that incredible feature set comes with associated bloat, and Photoshop is quickly becoming the juggernaut of image editors: yes, it gets the job done, but no, the job description should not include cruising down country roads.

Paint.NET straddles the middle ground between The GIMP and simple photo editors. You can download Paint.NET here.


There are two great, free alternatives to Photoshop. First, Paint.NET utilises the Microsoft .NET Framework to create a stable, lightweight program with nearly every major function the average user could want, from a Lasso tool to Gaussian blur. The interface is completely familiar, with the added benefit of translucent panels that make it easy to see what’s going on when the windows get cluttered. Paint.NET doesn’t yet support RAW format, however, which certainly limits its appeal.

If it’s not in The GIMP's default interface, there’s probably a plug-in for it. You can download The GIMP here.


The second major image editor far more closely rivals Photoshop in features and functionality, if not in appearance or price. The GIMP is a freeware editor that started off in Linux and was eventually ported to Windows, boosting its audience and popularity. It seems to include almost everything that Photoshop does: channels, layers, masks, more than 100 filters and effects, tabbed palettes, RAW support, editable text tools and colour operations such as levels. And if the feature you’re looking for isn’t in the main program, the chances are very high that someone has created a plug-in for it, including digital printing. Although the GIMP may be more difficult to install and start using than Photoshop, it takes less time to get up and running once you’ve got it set up the way you like.

Inkscape aims to create an open-source client that’s compliant with XML, SVG and CSS standards. You can download Inkscape here.


Photoshop is not the only Adobe design juggernaut with a free analogue. The tools in Illustrator, everybody’s favourite vector-graphics software, also can be emulated without too much fuss. Enter Inkscape. It’s not the only one of its kind, although it seems like it at times. Many of the now-essential tools found in its competition show up here, including paths, text, markers, clones, alpha blending, transforms, gradients, patterns and grouping. The program also supports Creative Commons metadata, node editing, layers, bitmap tracing and direct XML editing. It does all this, and more, without an enormous system footprint or any installation hassle.

Much like its siblings, Adobe Acrobat does its job well, except that it, too, can become a black hole for system resources. If you’re looking for a good PDF reader, Foxit PDF Reader has been a favourite, deserving of its popularity. It opens PDFs from the Web quickly and without hanging our system, not even for a few seconds. Adobe Reader has improved recently, but it can still take some time to load.

Primo PDF works by adding a 'Print' option to your existing software. You can download Primo PDF here.


PrimoPDF is a great PDF maker for similar reasons. It’s lightweight, with a small footprint, and is easy to use. Primo installs as a 'Print' option in every program you’ve got, so you can create a PDF using anything from HTML documents in Firefox to images in Paint.NET. Simple PDF publishing doesn’t need to be any more complicated than that.

Now let’s look at Adobe’s Dreamweaver. Although Dreamweaver is the acknowledged leader in the web design field (beating Microsoft's FrontPage), there have been full-featured web editors floating around since the early days of the web. KompoZer, built on the NVU architecture, is a good free option that's beginning to approach the functionality of Dreamweaver.

KompoZer’s three-tier toolbar is intuitive yet powerful. You can download KompoZer here.


The interface is different to Dreamweaver’s, but it should still feel familiar. Major editing buttons live in a three-tier toolbar at the top of the program that includes a one-click Publishing icon as well as one-click buttons for Image insertion and Table and Form creation. Font tweaks like Size and Style live in toolbars just below for easy HTML editing. A Site Manager, including File tree, is anchored on the left, although it can be collapsed. We didn’t notice any glitches when playing with the WYSIWYG function. Running lean and mean lets KompoZer compete more than adequately with better-known competitors.

As the cost of high-end graphics editing software rockets, and digitally produced art continues to improve in quality, it’s going to be increasingly difficult for struggling artists to acquire the tools they need. These programs show that not only can those tools be made for free, but in many cases they run better than the expensive paid-for industry standards.

See the following page for some free alternatives to Flash, Premiere, InDesign and other applications in Adobe's Creative Suite.

 

Talkback

Equivalent means "equal in value". I think we can all agree on that. But it really is mind-boggling to me how someone can call The Gimp and Photoshop equivalents.

I've used both a lot, and The Gimp is a good application for light graphical work and when it comes to digital media you can attain the same results in both applications. But when it comes to printed media, The Gimp does not have what it takes. No CMYK, no Pantone, no PDF creation. Neither does it have many of Photoshops essential workflow tools;
Non-destructive edits? No. Selection refinement tools? No. Easy exchange of data between Gimp and Inkscape? Proper support for vector graphics? A functional stroke tool? Layer groups? No. No. No. No.

I am a big Open Source fan. I use Ubuntu on all my servers, my laptop and my main workstation. I've used both Gimp and Inkscape a lot, but Inkscape still has a ways to go before reaching 1.0 and Gimps featureset is simply to small for graphics professionals nowadays.

And don't get me started on KompoZer... Sigh.

What really bothers me is that you post this article, acting as if our open source apps are as good as the products that Adobe has invested millions of dollars and years and years of development time into.
They are not, and pushing them as if they were is bound to cause a lot of people to be disappointed and disgruntled with Open Source.

Don't oversell our applications. Gimp is a good tool for non-professional work, but it should not be likened to Photoshop. Likewise with the other apps you mentioned. It's not that it can't be used for professional work, but it just does not have the quality that professionals expect. Yet.

1000146009 29 April, 2007 22:46
Reply

It wasn't our intention to 'push' open source alternatives to Adobe's applications by publishing this article; rather, it was simply to remind people that such choices exist. We also specifically asked for feedback from graphics professionals who have used both Adobe and open source apps, so thanks for your input.

What we will do is keep an eye on the development of open source apps like The GIMP, Inkscape et al, and in due course run full head-to-head reviews against their Adobe counterparts.

Charles McLellan 30 April, 2007 10:45
Reply

While we agree that Inkscape, The Gimp etc. are capable of lifting some, if not most, of the task that is accomplished, they are for all the reasons I mentioned earlier (and more) not of equal value.

Calling them equivalent is deliberately misleading and simply not true.

1000146009 30 April, 2007 21:48
Reply

Fair enough: although there was no intention to mislead, it so happens that the word 'equivalent' was substituted for 'analog' in the <a href="http://www.download.com/8301-2007_4-9714054-12.html?tag=more">original US-written article</a> in the editing process for the UK site (we routinely edit 'Americanisms'). We have now reinstated the original wording (with Anglicised spelling).

Charles McLellan 1 May, 2007 08:03
Reply

Or an app a standard? Way back in the early to mid 90s, creative types swore blind that it had to be Apple, then a couple of years later as Windows PCs became widely accepted in the sector, the insistence was for the Corel suite, with Quark.

Now it appears to be Adobe. So, which features in CS3 that were not in CS2 are professionally essential? How did professional users of CS2 get anything done without those features? CS1? Those Mac creatives of 10-15 years ago?

I'd be interested in the answer to this question:

what are the missing features of the open source software described in the article that would prevent a professional graphic artist from being productive? When were these features introduced in the proprietary world? When did they become commonplace? When did these features become essential?

Just interested...

putt1ck 3 May, 2007 08:54
Reply

I got Paint.NET installed on my pc, but I dont seem to handle it right...
I thought it was an alternative to regular Paint...
Free TV

April Rogers via Facebook 6 July, 2011 14:42
Reply

This post has been removed by a moderator.

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

KosGirl

Have there been any further updates to this story? I can't find any information on whether the hackers released the data or not.

39 minutes ago by KosGirl on Hackers hold bank to ransom over stolen data
SandJ

I have done 7 speed tests this morning on different speed test tools. They tell me my download speed is: 12.3, 12.3, 12.3, 11.1, 12.7, 12.7, 11.7...

1 hour ago by SandJ on Watchdog: TalkTalk's broadband speed test misled users
Jack Schofield

@Mary Microsoft could always send Mozilla a spec sheet and oblige them to meet the same standards as IE. Then Mozilla can spend millions of...

5 hours ago by Jack Schofield on Windows RT browsers and the point of Windows RT
goth1csnake3

Not before time, that people making films,dvd's get whats coming to them. Well done, Virgin Media.

7 hours ago by goth1csnake3 on Virgin Media: Spotify deal will bring down piracy
Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe

Apex - the question then is what about letting the user choose to have a tablet where they don't have to have that responsibility? why can't the...

17 hours ago by Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe on Windows RT browsers and the point of Windows RT
Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe

Moley, Apex, thanks; I think there's an interesting other dimension of choice - the choice to have a platform that is 'locked down' in the sense...

17 hours ago by Simon Bisson and Mary Branscombe on Mozilla accuses Microsoft of shutting Firefox out of WOA
Yellowcave

Not surprised. I once used the methods to let my firewall just notify me of breaches. Not one single logged event was genuine. Once, we all...

23 hours ago by Yellowcave on Mobile porn filters catch innocent content, says report
duplex

live realy sucks in facebook becuase people hack your profile

24 hours ago by duplex on Irish watchdog: Facebook privacy still falls short
Ed Macnair

If only it was that simple. When you start accessing Cloud applications you are stuck with the security model the vendor provides...........unless...

1 day ago by Ed Macnair via Facebook on IT security? You're doing it wrong!
Phil at Cloud4

Another good updaet, I have enjoyed going on the journey reading this series on SharePoint 2010 and have learned alot. Great writing.

1 day ago by Phil at Cloud4 on Designing a SharePoint farm: Tiers before bedtime
muteen

roumers of an ipad Mini, isnt that just an iTouch!?

1 day ago by muteen on Apple rebrands iPad 4G as 'Wi-Fi + Cellular' for UK
apexwm

Thanks for this article and bringing this issue to light. Unfortunately this type of activity is common not only with Adobe, but many other...

1 day ago by apexwm on Adobe move promotes piracy
Andy Bolstridge

there's a very thin line between tax avoidance and tax efficiency - earning £850 a month and claiming dividends to bring my income up to normal...

1 day ago by Andy Bolstridge via Facebook on The Idle Self-employed
Andy Bolstridge

I see that they are happy to announce these numbers.. but no-one will take any notice until they start announcing sales numbers too.

1 day ago by Andy Bolstridge via Facebook on Microsoft's score card for Smoked by Windows Phone
AndyPagin

I saw a Windows phone about a year ago, haven't seen once since, and quite a few people own phones in the City of London.

1 day ago by AndyPagin on Microsoft's score card for Smoked by Windows Phone
helice041

Well said. You can add the change differences between US $ and Euro for the adobe cloud subscription and the very clouded informations about when...

1 day ago by helice041 on Adobe move promotes piracy
John Barron

full link should be: http://piratebarron.wordpress.com/2012/05/12/escaping-the-walled-garden/ sorry

2 days ago by John Barron via Facebook on Court bans Dutch party from helping Pirate Bay
John Barron

Well, before this comes to the UK, as it's in the process of doing, it's time to opt out of censorship and surveillance, which I did yesterday:...

2 days ago by John Barron via Facebook on Court bans Dutch party from helping Pirate Bay
Jack Schofield

@ToulouseLePlot In this case, shipments are from manufacturers to sales channels, including outlets such as DSG, which owns PC World. They're not...

2 days ago by Jack Schofield on UK PC market grows as Western Europe declines
apexwm

Moley : Definitely agree with you and I think most of us draw our conclusions in haste, given the track record of Microsoft shutting out...

2 days ago by apexwm on Mozilla accuses Microsoft of shutting Firefox out of WOA