Advertisement
Promo

Application development Toolkit

Story: UK Patent Office under fire over software report

  • Previous comment

Posted by: Alex Hudson (Monday 8 November 2004, 11:17 PM)

  • Reply

When I said,

"Whether software has a technical contribution is a function of how well you write software," said Hudson. "It is very, very easy to find technical contribution in software."

... I meant to say "..is a function of how well you write your patent application" (maybe I just said 'application', which could have meant either). But, it's mostly true anyway.

I am surprised that the UKPTO describe their "Fact & Fiction" document as an "aggregate of opinion". Firstly, it cannot be an aggregate, because it doesn't reflect our opinions at any stage: it only presents one side of the debate (the side they favour). Secondly, how can it possibly be a "Fact" leaflet if it's made up of opinions?

This is merely a UKPTO propaganda exercise to try to get people back onto their side. They realise that they are losing the argument to broaden software patents out, and are getting called on their double-speak.

  • Previous comment

  • Reply to this comment
  • Return to story
  • Report this as offensive


Full Talkback thread

Video icon

Video

Featured Talkback

In association with Network Liberation Movement
The fact is: Software developers today are really designers and not coders. The reason that business anlaysts exist today to model solutions is because they understand the value of designing software before writing it. All too often developers create code that has little value because they do not understand that business classes interact with other classes within the confines of a working model or pattern.

By: 1000165269

Read full story:
Making sense of agile modelling


Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links

Help

Become part of the ZDNet community.

Newsletters