ZDNet UK


Skip to Main Content

ZDNet.co.uk - Winner of Best Business Website 2007
  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Blogs
  4. Reviews
  5. Prices
  6. Resources
  7. Community
  8. My ZDNet

 

ZDNet UK RSS Feeds


IT Jobs

Office applications Toolkit

Story: Do video games make children violent?

  • Previous comment

Posted by: Anonymous (Friday 25 February 2005, 5:01 PM)

  • Reply

I could not agree more with those posts about bad parenting. Look people, we're all tired of this debate - the facts are simple.

Violent video games do no more to a child than violent movies, violent tv shows, etc. The fact is, we live in a violent society. Our legislature "patches" things, rather than fixes them.

If anyone cares to actually fix this problem, we need to recognize the following:

PLACE THE BLAME WHERE APPROPRIATE:

1. Only in America could this happen without anyone asking why the hell the kid had a gun to begin with. Why should we have stronger legislation over video games than we do over guns? Obviously if a child can get a hold of a weapon, does anyone seriously think acquiring a video game would be a stretch?

2. Only in America could this happen without anyone questioning the parents. Guess what, parenting is tough - if you can't handle it - don't have a kid. The fact of the matter is, most parents are awful parents. Parenting adults LOVE to make excuses as to their shortcomings (and to convince themselves that they are a good parent). The fact is, if you ever hear yourself saying "I'm at work all day..," or "I'm a single parent...," or "I can't control them all of the time...," then guess what? Chances are, you're one of the 'bad parents' everyone loves to talk objectively about. If you are a good parent, you have open communication with your child, you have instilled in them a sense of discipline and honesty, and you know where they are and what they're doing at ALL TIMES. No excuses.

So what is the solution? It's simple. Pass parenting legislature. More specifically, make it into law that parents are DIRECTLY responsible for the actions of their children until they are 18. How about that? If your kid goes and kills three policemen (a horrible tragedy), then YOU go to prison.

How about we make a real law, at the heart of the problem, with some real teeth. Some real accountability for the actions of our society. The fact is, this would never pass, but not because it isn't a good idea, but because we would end up sending thousands (maybe millions?) of parents to prison.

In every case like this (Columbine, Arkansas, etc.), how come I know the names of the video games involved, but not the names of the parents? Why does the media spend all of its airtime attacking the games industry, instead of the parents? In my mind, they could have prevented these acts.

3. "What ever happened to crazy?" -Chris Rock. Repeat that line a couple of times to let it sink in. Look at the statistics: well over 99.9% of video gamers are not commiting these crimes. Since when did the 0.1% of society dictate the laws of the many? The fact is, at least 0.1% of our society is violent, and commits violent crimes. We need a way to combat this problem at its source (which is parenting), rather than merely patching the symptoms.

  • Previous comment

  • Reply to this comment
  • Return to story
  • Report this as offensive


Full Talkback thread

Story: Do video games make children violent?

  1. No!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!... lewis schofile
  2. No !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I have played... joe bacthelor
  3. I have a WAY WAY better place to put the game... Matt Vandermolen
  4. Turkey GObbles Taco & Burrito
  5. violent games are the one thing that stops me... Philip
  6. DON'T DO DRUGS!! THEY KILL NOT SUICIDAL
  7. I think it should be 16. Matt Rowe
  8. i hate the grand theft auto games even tho i never... Anonymous
  9. This ban thing is bull crap. Mostly all that stuff... Brandon
  10. I dont think that it is the video games that... Anonymous
  11. Video games don't kill people. If kids kill t... Gerett Diamond
  12. You are right! in colombine the kids were dis... james eblin
  13. Q: Do video games make children violent? A: you be... samuel
  14. I think it is pathetic that you blame video games... Anonymous
  15. Drugs kill not video games Anonymous
  16. Violent video games make children for violent... Anonymous
  17. I could not agree more with those posts about bad... Anonymous
  18. NO!!!! Kids just say that to get themselves out of... Joey
  19. Absolute crap. Video games are used as an excuse f... NJ
  20. i am 13 yrs old and my parents wont let me bu... anonymous
  21. Games do NOT make children violent. Sure it causes... Kelsey
  22. Video games are made for entertainment. Peop... Chris
  23. jeebus.....some people are wack.....make that a lo... Hwarang
  24. Dear to all the idiots that believe that vide... Christie
  25. Video games don't make children violent. I have be... Ryan
  26. we are doin a debate. and we are on the side... Anonymous
  27. i think its bull shit lilt
  28. NO, VIDEO GAMES DON'T MAKE KIDS VIOLENT. All you p... Mike Jones
  29. Personally, idk wtf you guys are trying to ac... the plague
  30. ITS SILLY TO BLAM GTA because its the parnents fua... Anonymous
  31. NoOOOoOOo! iam 15 and i have been playing 18 rate... Carl
  32. i doing a debate and i need information plz mail m... the lil guy
  33. I think that some games are cool but if your under... TASHA
  34. no at lest not me I play violent video games but i... Anonymous
  35. If the stores that sell the video games just hand... Anonymous
  36. All these people who say they dont make children v... Anonymous
  37. YES!!!!! To the majority of responsible adults out... TO ALL GAMING IDIOTS
  38. MY NAME IS ADAM I THINK THAT SCREEN BASED MEDIA DO... Anonymous
  39. I agree with these comments. These 'lawmakers... Anonymous
  40. I think that playing any type of video games, watc... emily
  41. Video games do not promt kids to be violent.... THE T-MAN
  42. VIDEO GAMES DO NOT CAUSE PEOPLE TO ACT VIOLENT, IF... HOMER-2006
  43. I don't feel like these things need to be enforced... Sam Webb
  44. If it wasn't for violent games, I'd kill you all. Josh
  45. Video games bad? I don't think so! I've been playi... JM
  46. It is not video games that are bad. If you don't w... james eblin
  47. No, Video games don't make children violent. If th... James Waller
  48. in this whole article all the points against vgame... marshall shannon
  49. Rick James agrees with you Mike Jones RickJames

Back to: Do video games make children violent?


Featured Talkback

Why do so many (virtually all) software packages think that they are so important that they have to be started automatically every time the computer boots? What is the largest number of "speed access", "update check", "camera download" and whatever other background programs you have ever seen running? Of those, how many did you really need?

By: J.A. Watson

Read full story:
Annoying software: a rogues' gallery

Discussions

stl_saint stl_saint

long time coming....

Thursday 21 August 2008, 3:47 AM

1 comment
stl_saint stl_saint

moving in the right direction

Thursday 21 August 2008, 3:43 AM

1 comment

Vista Upgrade Blog

Official MS Windows 7 Bloggers

Check this out: http://blogs.msdn.com/e7...spx Its an official blog "Engineering Windows 7" Nothing. That's what is revealed. Until there is real... More

4 comments

Microsoft's Mojave just a desert vista

It didn't seem fair to wade into Microsoft's “Mojave Experiment” advert quite so soon after the flat earth incident. But The Economist has no such qualms: in this week's issue, it wonders... More

6 comments

... But Still a Few Things Amiss (with...

It's not all roses with Vista, of course. I had my first BSOD over the weekend, when I was turning the laptop back on after suspending it. They typical long blurb about "If this is... More

5 comments