Advertisement
Promo

Online business Toolkit

Story: Wind up the Internet Watch Foundation

  • Previous comment

Posted by: 1000238123 (Tuesday 9 December 2008, 4:58 PM)

  • Reply

More ignorance

All I am saying as this case does not open any real debate into censorship and a "free" society.

I think its entirely reasonable that the state prevents children from watching certain films. The state has also decided that its reasonable to prevent adults from viewing certain things. I think everyone except peodophiles probably agrees with where the line has been drawn. The only debate should be over its implementation.

It really annoys me that people invoke the free society ideal. I don't think that the people who use that phrase have any idea about what it means. Does a free society have laws? Can a free society have liable? To pragmatists the answer is yes, censorship is fine, a free society is one that does not contain slaves. Censoring child pornography has nothing to do with a practicle implementation of a free society. Infact allowing child pornography to be viewed and become profitable is the real threat to a free society, becuase the children involved have not made a free choice to participate.

Using this story as evidence for why censorship is questionable is morally wrong. The real agenda behind this article is an anti-DRM and an anti-patent ideology. This article does nothing but hurt that argument (which I am for). I am asking the freedom for information to consider there choices for battlegrounds more carefully.

Private message disabled

1000238123

1000238123
n/a
Member since: December 2005

Site Activity Rating:

3

 


  • Previous comment

  • Reply to this comment
  • Return to story
  • Report this as offensive


Full Talkback thread

Sentry Posts Blog

Security Videos by Industry Leaders

The Academy Pro presents vendor and open source security products in video format. The 500+ free videos cover everything from firewalls, penetration testing, IDS/IPS to NAC and anti-spam.... More

Post a comment

Civil liberties groups attack file-sha...

Civil liberties and digital rights organisations have strongly criticised Lord Mandelson's Digital Economy Bill. Liberty said in a position paper on Tuesday that the bill, part of... More

Post a comment

Authentication risks all too human

Risks to successful online banking identification and authentication using smartcards involve a mixture of human and technological factors, according to the European Network and Information... More

1 comment

Google Chrome

Roundup: Full coverage of Google Chrome

The search giant has launched a beta of its own open-source browser, sending a clear challenge to Microsoft in the way it lets users work with applications More

Blog: Google Chrome has Microsoft's code inside, says MS manager

And furthermore, he says, that's a good thing... More

Blog: Google Chrome — nine things we've found since launch

Google must be very happy with the coverage Chrome has gathered. But it's not all good news... More


Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links

Help

Become part of the ZDNet community.

Newsletters