Advertisement
Promo

Security threats Toolkit

Story: ISP: Wi-Fi test shows flaw in file-sharing crackdown

  • Previous comment

Posted by: Moley (Monday 19 October 2009, 7:21 PM)

  • Reply

The horse has bolted

The action that should have been taken, when file sharing was in it's infancy, was to target the suppliers and facilitators of files to be shared, rather than the 'consumer'. Their actions surely were illegal under any kind of regime, without resorting to any new legislation, and if not, legislation could have been quickly enough passed.

This, as I understand it, is also now the preferred method of dealing with another intransigent problem - drugs.

There is, and never was, any moral justification for wholesale file sharing. I'm not a Troll, I just do not like being subject to ever more restrictive (draconian) regimes as a result of certain other people's bad behaviour. Not only file sharing, of course, and not only on the internet (e.g. I.D. Cards, 'Vet and Bar' etc. etc. etc.).

Moley

Moley
Retired, UK
Member since: January 2004

Site Activity Rating:

5

This member is ranked #15 in our top 100


  • Previous comment

  • Reply to this comment
  • Return to story
  • Report this as offensive


Full Talkback thread

Sentry Posts Blog

McKinnon lawyers seek judicial review

Lawyers seeking a judicial review for Nasa hacker Gary McKinnon lodged fresh evidence of his psychiatric state at the High Court on Thursday. Karen Todner, McKinnon's solicitor,... More

1 comment

Beware of keeping your head in the clo...

Information security professionals can look forward to a deepening appreciation for their skills as security continues to be recognised as an essential element for doing business in... More

1 comment

Civil liberties groups attack file-sha...

Civil liberties and digital rights organisations have strongly criticised Lord Mandelson's Digital Economy Bill. Liberty said in a position paper on Tuesday that the bill, part of... More

Post a comment

Win a BlackBerry with Vlingo voice recognition

Win a BlackBerry with Vlingo voice recognition

What is ZDNet UK's usual tagline?

Competition closes - 14 Jan 2010


Skip Sub Navigation Links to CNET Brand Links

Help

Become part of the ZDNet community.

Newsletters