Security threats Toolkit
Story: ISP: Wi-Fi test shows flaw in file-sharing crackdown
The horse has bolted
The action that should have been taken, when file sharing was in it's infancy, was to target the suppliers and facilitators of files to be shared, rather than the 'consumer'. Their actions surely were illegal under any kind of regime, without resorting to any new legislation, and if not, legislation could have been quickly enough passed.
This, as I understand it, is also now the preferred method of dealing with another intransigent problem - drugs.
There is, and never was, any moral justification for wholesale file sharing. I'm not a Troll, I just do not like being subject to ever more restrictive (draconian) regimes as a result of certain other people's bad behaviour. Not only file sharing, of course, and not only on the internet (e.g. I.D. Cards, 'Vet and Bar' etc. etc. etc.).
Moley
Retired, UK
Member since: January 2004
Site Activity Rating:
This member is ranked #15 in our top 100
Full Talkback thread
Story: ISP: Wi-Fi test shows flaw in file-sharing crackdown
-
Yup spot on.. CA -
Pointless and inneffective 1000215420 -
The horse has bolted Moley -
Most people are crooks if given half a chance mrjonno -
are you joking? CA -
Very serious mrjonno -
Flawed analogy 1000215420 -
Re: Flawed Analogy Moley -
Only punishment can really sto... mrjonno -
Wrong! Tezzer -
Re: Only punishment can really... Moley -
If only 1 in a 1000 people ste... mrjonno -
Is there a particular point yo... mrjonno -
..... CA -
Shades of Hitler 1000215420 -
Not really Tezzer -
ip isn't just about large... ator1940
Back to: ISP: Wi-Fi test shows flaw in file-sharing crackdown









